Reflexive governance architectures: Considering the ethical implications of autonomous technology adoption in food supply chains. (March 2023)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Manning, Louise; Brewer, Steve; Craigon, Peter J.; Frey, Jeremy; Gutierrez, Anabel; Jacobs, Naomi; Kanza, Samantha; Munday, Samuel; Sacks, Justin; Pearson, Simon
• Is Part Of: Trends in food science & technology. Volume 133(2023)
• Page Start: 114
• Page End: 126
• Publication Date: 2023-03
• Subjects: Data -- Ethical aspects -- Ethical outcomes -- Reflective governance -- Reflexive governance -- AI -- Food supply; Food industry and trade -- Periodicals; Food -- Biotechnology -- Periodicals; 664.005
• DOI: 10.1016/j.tifs.2023.01.015
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0924-2244

Abstract

Abstract: Background: The application of autonomous technology in food supply chains gives rise to a number of ethical considerations associated with the interaction between human and technology, human-technology-plant and human-technology-animal. These considerations and their implications influence technology design, the ways in which technology is applied, how the technology changes food supply chain practices, decision-making and the associated ethical aspects and outcomes. Scope and approach: Using the concept of reflexive governance, this paper has critiqued existing reflective food-related ethical assessment tools and proposed the structural elements required for reflexive governance architectures which address both the sharing of data, and the use of artificial intelligence (AI) and machine learning in food supply chains. Key findings and conclusions: Considering the ethical implications of using autonomous technology in real life contexts is challenging. The current approach, focusing on discrete ethical elements in isolation e.g., ethical aspects or outcomes, normative standards or ethically orientated compliance-based business strategies, is not sufficient in itself. Alternatively, the application of more holistic, reflexive governance architectures can inform consideration of ethical aspects, potential ethical outcomes, in particular how they are interlinked and/or interdependent, and the need for mitigation at all lifecycle stages of technology and food product conceptualisation, design, realisation and adoption in the food supply chain. This research is of interest to those who are undertaking ethical deliberation on data sharing, and the use of AI and machine learning in food supply chains. Highlights: Autonomous technology can support decision-making in food supply chains. The use of autonomous technology has ethical implications. Ethical considerations focus on both aspects and outcomes of technology use. Existing governance approaches are limited by being reflective, normative, rule-based. Reflexive governance architectures for technology 'concept to realisation' are essential.