Beyond the Simple View of Reading: The Role of Executive Functions in Emergent Bilinguals' and English Monolinguals' Reading Comprehension. (2nd March 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Taboada Barber, Ana; Cartwright, Kelly B.; Hancock, Gregory R.; Klauda, Susan Lutz
• Is Part Of: Reading research quarterly. Volume 56(2021)Supplement 1
• Page Start: S45
• Page End: S64
• Publication Date: 2021-03-02
• Subjects: Comprehension -- Decoding -- Language learners -- Oral language -- Theoretical perspectives -- Cognitive -- Comprehension (General) -- Decoding—sight words / word recognition -- English Language Learners -- Cognitive Processes -- Listening Comprehension -- LISREL/Causal Modeling -- 2‐Childhood; Reading -- Periodicals; Reading -- Research -- Periodicals; Lecture -- Périodiques; Lecture -- Recherche -- Périodiques; 428.4
• DOI: 10.1002/rrq.385
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0034-0553

Abstract

ABSTRACT: The simple view of reading describes reading as the product of decoding (D) and listening comprehension (LC). However, the simple view of reading has been challenged, and evidence has proved it to be too simple to explain the complexities of reading comprehension in the elementary school years. Hypotheses have been advanced that there are cognitive‐linguistic factors that underlie the common variance between D and LC, which are malleable, although there is no clarity at this point regarding what these are. We propose that one such group of malleable cognitive factors is executive function (EF) skills. Further, we posit that EF skills play equally strong roles in explaining reading comprehension variance in emergent bilinguals and English monolinguals. We used multigroup structural equation modeling to determine the contribution of these constructs (D, LC, and EF) to reading comprehension in 425 emergent bilinguals and 302 English monolinguals in grades 2–4. The shared variance between D and LC was explained by direct and indirect effects in the models tested, with strong indirect effects for the EFs of cognitive flexibility and working memory through D and LC, respectively, for both language groups. The indirect effect of cognitive flexibility through LC on reading comprehension was considerably larger for emergent bilinguals than for English monolinguals. Considerations for a more nuanced view of the simple view of reading and its implications for practice are discussed.