The effectiveness of foreign jurisdiction clauses in Nigeria: an empirical inquiry. (2nd January 2023)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Yekini, Abubakri
• Is Part Of: Journal of private international law. Volume 19:Number 1(2023)
• Page Start: 67
• Page End: 91
• Publication Date: 2023-01-02
• Subjects: foreign jurisdiction clause -- choice of court agreements -- forum non conveniens -- ouster clauses -- B2B commercial transactions; Conflict of laws -- Periodicals; 340.905
• DOI: 10.1080/17441048.2023.2189102
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1757-8418

Abstract

Abstract : Business entities do not often include terms in commercial agreements unless those terms are relevant and are designed to maximise the gains of the parties to the agreement. To realise their reasonable and legitimate expectations, they expect that contractual terms and promises would be respected by the parties and courts. There is a growing body of literature suggesting that Nigerian courts are not giving maximum effects to foreign jurisdiction clauses (FJC). What is largely missing from the scholarly contributions is that no one has worked out a principled solution to overcome this conundrum. This article significantly contributes to the existing literature through an empirical analysis of Nigerian appellate court decisions on FJCs with a view to gaining deeper insights into the attitude of Nigerian courts to FJCs. Compared to the US where the national average of enforcement is 74%, a 40% rate for Nigeria does not project Nigeria as a pro-business forum. This outlook can potentially disincentivise cross-border trade and commerce between Nigeria and the rest of the world. To address this problem, the paper proceeds by presenting a normative framework, built principally on economic and contract theories, for enforcing FJCs. As most of the cases are B2B transactions, the paper invites the courts to treat FJCs and arbitration clauses equally and to replace forum non conveniens considerations with a more principled approach which limits non-enforcement to overriding policy, and a strong cause that is defined by reasonableness and foreseeability.