Overestimation of stereo thresholds by the TNO stereotest is not due to global stereopsis. (23rd March 2017)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Vancleef, Kathleen; Read, Jenny C. A.; Herbert, William; Goodship, Nicola; Woodhouse, Maeve; Serrano‐Pedraza, Ignacio
• Is Part Of: Ophthalmic and physiological optics. Volume 37:Number 4(2017:Jul.)
• Page Start: 507
• Page End: 520
• Publication Date: 2017-03-23
• Subjects: randot stereotest -- global stereopsis -- local stereopsis -- random dot stereogram -- stereo threshold -- TNO stereotest; Ophthalmology -- Periodicals; Physiological optics -- Periodicals; Optometry -- Periodicals; Optics -- Periodicals; Vision -- Periodicals; 617.75
• DOI: 10.1111/opo.12371
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0275-5408

Abstract

Abstract: Purpose: It has been repeatedly shown that the TNO stereotest overestimates stereo threshold compared to other clinical stereotests. In the current study, we test whether this overestimation can be attributed to a distinction between 'global' (or 'cyclopean') and 'local' (feature or contour‐based) stereopsis. Methods: We compared stereo thresholds of a global (TNO) and a local clinical stereotest (Randot Circles). In addition, a global and a local psychophysical stereotest were added to the design. One hundred and forty‐nine children between 4 and 16 years old were included in the study. Results: Stereo threshold estimates with TNO were a factor of two higher than with any of the other stereotests. No significant differences were found between the other tests. Bland‐Altman analyses also indicated low agreement between TNO and the other stereotests, especially for higher stereo threshold estimates. Simulations indicated that the TNO test protocol and test disparities can account for part of this effect. Discussion: The results indicate that the global – local distinction is an unlikely explanation for the overestimated thresholds of TNO. Test protocol and disparities are one contributing factor. Potential additional factors include the nature of the task (TNO requires depth discrimination rather than detection) and the use of anaglyph red/green 3D glasses rather than polarizing filters, which may reduce binocular fusion.