Risk stratification of patients admitted to hospital with covid-19 using the ISARIC WHO Clinical Characterisation Protocol: development and validation of the 4C Mortality Score. (9th September 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Knight, Stephen R; Ho, Antonia; Pius, Riinu; Buchan, Iain; Carson, Gail; Drake, Thomas M; Dunning, Jake; Fairfield, Cameron J; Gamble, Carrol; Green, Christopher A; Gupta, Rishi; Halpin, Sophie; Hardwick, Hayley E; Holden, Karl A; Horby, Peter W; Jackson, Clare; Mclean, Kenneth A; Merson, Laura; Nguyen-Van-Tam, Jonathan S; Norman, Lisa; Noursadeghi, Mahdad; Olliaro, Piero L; Pritchard, Mark G; Russell, Clark D; Shaw, Catherine A; Sheikh, Aziz; Solomon, Tom; Sudlow, Cathie; Swann, Olivia V; Turtle, Lance CW; Openshaw, Peter JM; Baillie, J Kenneth; Semple, Malcolm G; Docherty, Annemarie B; Harrison, Ewen M;
• Other Names: author non-byline.; Baillie J Kenneth author non-byline.; Semple Malcolm G author non-byline.; Openshaw Peter JM author non-byline.; Carson Gail author non-byline.; Alex Beatrice author non-byline.; Bach Benjamin author non-byline.; Barclay Wendy S author non-byline.; Bogaert Debby author non-byline.; Chand Meera author non-byline.; Cooke Graham S author non-byline.; Docherty Annemarie B author non-byline.; Dunning Jake author non-byline.; da Silva Filipe Ana author non-byline.; Fletcher Tom author non-byline.; Green Christopher A author non-byline.; Harrison Ewen M author non-byline.; Hiscox Julian A author non-byline.; Ho Antonia Ying Wai author non-byline.; Horby Peter W author non-byline.; Ijaz Samreen author non-byline.; Khoo Saye author non-byline.; Klenerman Paul author non-byline.; Law Andrew author non-byline.; Lim Wei Shen author non-byline.; Mentzer Alexander J author non-byline.; Merson Laura author non-byline.; Meynert Alison M author non-byline.; Noursadeghi Mahdad author non-byline.; Moore Shona C author non-byline.; Palmarini Massimo author non-byline.; Paxton William A author non-byline.; Pollakis Georgios author non-byline.; Price Nicholas author non-byline.; Rambaut Andrew author non-byline.; Robertson David L author non-byline.; Russell Clark D author non-byline.; Sancho-Shimizu Vanessa author non-byline.; Scott Janet T author non-byline.; Sigfrid Louise author non-byline.; Solomon Tom author non-byline.; Sriskandan Shiranee author non-byline.; Stuart David author non-byline.; Summers Charlotte author non-byline.; Tedder Richard S author non-byline.; Thomson Emma C author non-byline.; Thwaites Ryan S author non-byline.; Turtle Lance CW author non-byline.; Zambon Maria author non-byline.; Hardwick Hayley author non-byline.; Donohue Chloe author non-byline.; Ewins Jane author non-byline.; Oosthuyzen Wilna author non-byline.; Griffiths Fiona author non-byline.; Norman Lisa author non-byline.; Pius Riinu author non-byline.; Drake Tom M author non-byline.; Fairfield Cameron J author non-byline.; Knight Stephen author non-byline.; Mclean Kenneth A author non-byline.; Murphy Derek author non-byline.; Shaw Catherine A author non-byline.; Dalton Jo author non-byline.; Girvan Michelle author non-byline.; Saviciute Egle author non-byline.; Roberts Stephanie author non-byline.; Harrison Janet author non-byline.; Marsh Laura author non-byline.; Connor Marie author non-byline.; Halpin Sophie author non-byline.; Jackson Clare author non-byline.; Gamble Carrol author non-byline.; Leeming Gary author non-byline.; Law Andrew author non-byline.; Hendry Ross author non-byline.; Scott-Brown James author non-byline.; Greenhalf William author non-byline.; Shaw Victoria author non-byline.; McDonald Sarah author non-byline.; Ahmed Katie A author non-byline.; Armstrong Jane A author non-byline.; Ashworth Milton author non-byline.; Asiimwe Innocent G author non-byline.; Bakshi Siddharth author non-byline.; Barlow Samantha L author non-byline.; Booth Laura author non-byline.; Brennan Benjamin author non-byline.; Bullock Katie author non-byline.; Catterall Benjamin WA author non-byline.; Clark Jordan J author non-byline.; Clarke Emily A author non-byline.; Cole Sarah author non-byline.; Cooper Louise author non-byline.; Cox Helen author non-byline.; Davis Christopher author non-byline.; Dincarslan Oslem author non-byline.; Dunn Chris author non-byline.; Dyer Philip author non-byline.; Elliott Angela author non-byline.; Evans Anthony author non-byline.; Fisher Lewis WS author non-byline.; Foster Terry author non-byline.; Garcia-Dorival Isabel author non-byline.; Greenhalf Willliam author non-byline.; Gunning Philip author non-byline.; Hartley Catherine author non-byline.; Ho Antonia author non-byline.; Jensen Rebecca L author non-byline.; Jones Christopher B author non-byline.; Jones Trevor R author non-byline.; Khandaker Shadia author non-byline.; King Katharine author non-byline.; Kiy Robyn T author non-byline.; Koukorava Chrysa author non-byline.; Lake Annette author non-byline.; Lant Suzannah author non-byline.; Latawiec Diane author non-byline.; Lavelle-Langham L author non-byline.; Lefteri Daniella author non-byline.; Lett Lauren author non-byline.; Livoti Lucia A author non-byline.; Mancini Maria author non-byline.; McDonald Sarah author non-byline.; McEvoy Laurence author non-byline.; McLauchlan John author non-byline.; Metelmann Soeren author non-byline.; Miah Nahida S author non-byline.; Middleton Joanna author non-byline.; Mitchell Joyce author non-byline.; Moore Shona C author non-byline.; Murphy Ellen G author non-byline.; Penrice-Randal Rebekah author non-byline.; Pilgrim Jack author non-byline.; Prince Tessa author non-byline.; Reynolds Will author non-byline.; Ridley P Matthew author non-byline.; Sales Debby author non-byline.; Shaw Victoria E author non-byline.; Shears Rebecca K author non-byline.; Small Benjamin author non-byline.; Subramaniam Krishanthi S author non-byline.; Szemiel Agnieska author non-byline.; Taggart Aislynn author non-byline.; Tanianis-Hughes Jolanta author non-byline.; Thomas Jordan author non-byline.; Trochu Erwan author non-byline.; van Tonder Libby author non-byline.; Wilcock Eve author non-byline.; Zhang J Eunice author non-byline.; Adeniji Kayode author non-byline.; Agranoff Daniel author non-byline.; Agwuh Ken author non-byline.; Ail Dhiraj author non-byline.; Alegria Ana author non-byline.; Angus Brian author non-byline.; Ashish Abdul author non-byline.; Atkinson Dougal author non-byline.; Bari Shahedal author non-byline.; Barlow Gavin author non-byline.; Barnass Stella author non-byline.; Barrett Nicholas author non-byline.; Bassford Christopher author non-byline.; Baxter David author non-byline.; Beadsworth Michael author non-byline.; Bernatoniene Jolanta author non-byline.; Berridge John author non-byline.; Best Nicola author non-byline.; Bothma Pieter author non-byline.; Brealey David author non-byline.; Brittain-Long Robin author non-byline.; Bulteel Naomi author non-byline.; Burden Tom author non-byline.; Burtenshaw Andrew author non-byline.; Caruth Vikki author non-byline.; Chadwick David author non-byline.; Chambler Duncan author non-byline.; Chee Nigel author non-byline.; Child Jenny author non-byline.; Chukkambotla Srikanth author non-byline.; Clark Tom author non-byline.; Collini Paul author non-byline.; Cosgrove Catherine author non-byline.; Cupitt Jason author non-byline.; Cutino-Moguel Maria-Teresa author non-byline.; Dark Paul author non-byline.; Dawson Chris author non-byline.; Dervisevic Samir author non-byline.; Donnison Phil author non-byline.; Douthwaite Sam author non-byline.; DuRand Ingrid author non-byline.; Dushianthan Ahilanadan author non-byline.; Dyer Tristan author non-byline.; Evans Cariad author non-byline.; Eziefula Chi author non-byline.; Fegan Chrisopher author non-byline.; Finn Adam author non-byline.; Fullerton Duncan author non-byline.; Garg Sanjeev author non-byline.; Garg Sanjeev author non-byline.; Garg Atul author non-byline.; Godden Jo author non-byline.; Goldsmith Arthur author non-byline.; Graham Clive author non-byline.; Hardy Elaine author non-byline.; Hartshorn Stuart author non-byline.; Harvey Daniel author non-byline.; Havalda Peter author non-byline.; Hawcutt Daniel B author non-byline.; Hobrok Maria author non-byline.; Hodgson Luke author non-byline.; Holme Anita author non-byline.; Hormis Anil author non-byline.; Jacobs Michael author non-byline.; Jain Susan author non-byline.; Jennings Paul author non-byline.; Kaliappan Agilan author non-byline.; Kasipandian Vidya author non-byline.; Kegg Stephen author non-byline.; Kelsey Michael author non-byline.; Kendall Jason author non-byline.; Kerrison Caroline author non-byline.; Kerslake Ian author non-byline.; Koch Oliver author non-byline.; Koduri Gouri author non-byline.; Koshy George author non-byline.; Laha Shondipon author non-byline.; Larkin Susan author non-byline.; Leiner Tamas author non-byline.; Lillie Patrick author non-byline.; Limb James author non-byline.; Linnett Vanessa author non-byline.; Little Jeff author non-byline.; MacMahon Michael author non-byline.; MacNaughton Emily author non-byline.; Mankregod Ravish author non-byline.; Masson Huw author non-byline.; Matovu Elijah author non-byline.; McCullough Katherine author non-byline.; McEwen Ruth author non-byline.; Meda Manjula author non-byline.; Mills Gary author non-byline.; Minton Jane author non-byline.; Mirfenderesky Mariyam author non-byline.; Mohandas Kavya author non-byline.; Mok Quen author non-byline.; Moon James author non-byline.; Moore Elinoor author non-byline.; Morgan Patrick author non-byline.; Morris Craig author non-byline.; Mortimore Katherine author non-byline.; Moses Samuel author non-byline.; Mpenge Mbiye author non-byline.; Mulla Rohinton author non-byline.; Murphy Michael author non-byline.; Nagel Megan author non-byline.; Nagarajan Thapas author non-byline.; Nelson Mark author non-byline.; Otahal Igor author non-byline.; Pais Mark author non-byline.; Panchatsharam Selva author non-byline.; Paraiso Hassan author non-byline.; Patel Brij author non-byline.; Pepperell Justin author non-byline.; Peters Mark author non-byline.; Phull Mandeep author non-byline.; Pintus Stefania author non-byline.; Pooni Jagtur Singh author non-byline.; Post Frank author non-byline.; Price David author non-byline.; Prout Rachel author non-byline.; Rae Nikolas author non-byline.; Reschreiter Henrik author non-byline.; Reynolds Tim author non-byline.; Richardson Neil author non-byline.; Roberts Mark author non-byline.; Roberts Devender author non-byline.; Rose Alistair author non-byline.; Rousseau Guy author non-byline.; Ryan Brendan author non-byline.; Saluja Taranprit author non-byline.; Shah Aarti author non-byline.; Shanmuga Prad author non-byline.; Sharma Anil author non-byline.; Shawcross Anna author non-byline.; Sizer Jeremy author non-byline.; Smith Richard author non-byline.; Snelson Catherine author non-byline.; Spittle Nick author non-byline.; Staines Nikki author non-byline.; Stambach Tom author non-byline.; Stewart Richard author non-byline.; Subudhi Pradeep author non-byline.; Szakmany Tamas author non-byline.; Tatham Kate author non-byline.; Thomas Jo author non-byline.; Thompson Chris author non-byline.; Thompson Robert author non-byline.; Tridente Ascanio author non-byline.; Tupper-Carey Darell author non-byline.; Twagira Mary author non-byline.; Ustianowski Andrew author non-byline.; Vallotton Nick author non-byline.; Vincent-Smith Lisa author non-byline.; Visuvanathan Shico author non-byline.; Vuylsteke Alan author non-byline.; Waddy Sam author non-byline.; Wake Rachel author non-byline.; Walden Andrew author non-byline.; Welters Ingeborg author non-byline.; Whitehouse Tony author non-byline.; Whittaker Paul author non-byline.; Whittington Ashley author non-byline.; Wijesinghe Meme author non-byline.; Williams Martin author non-byline.; Wilson Lawrence author non-byline.; Wilson Sarah author non-byline.; Winchester Stephen author non-byline.; Wiselka Martin author non-byline.; Wolverson Adam author non-byline.; Wooton Daniel G author non-byline.; Workman Andrew author non-byline.; Yates Bryan author non-byline.; Young Peter author non-byline.;
• Is Part Of: BMJ. Volume 370(2020)
• Publication Date: 2020-09-09
• Subjects: Medicine -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals; Medicine; Periodicals; 610
• DOI: 10.1136/bmj.m3339
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0007-1447

Abstract

Abstract: Objective: To develop and validate a pragmatic risk score to predict mortality in patients admitted to hospital with coronavirus disease 2019 (covid-19). Design: Prospective observational cohort study. Setting: International Severe Acute Respiratory and emerging Infections Consortium (ISARIC) World Health Organization (WHO) Clinical Characterisation Protocol UK (CCP-UK) study (performed by the ISARIC Coronavirus Clinical Characterisation Consortium—ISARIC-4C) in 260 hospitals across England, Scotland, and Wales. Model training was performed on a cohort of patients recruited between 6 February and 20 May 2020, with validation conducted on a second cohort of patients recruited after model development between 21 May and 29 June 2020 . Participants: Adults (age ≥18 years) admitted to hospital with covid-19 at least four weeks before final data extraction. Main outcome measure: In-hospital mortality. Results: 35 463 patients were included in the derivation dataset (mortality rate 32.2%) and 22 361 in the validation dataset (mortality rate 30.1%). The final 4C Mortality Score included eight variables readily available at initial hospital assessment: age, sex, number of comorbidities, respiratory rate, peripheral oxygen saturation, level of consciousness, urea level, and C reactive protein (score range 0-21 points). The 4C Score showed high discrimination for mortality (derivation cohort: area under the receiver operating characteristic curve 0.79, 95% confidence interval 0.78 to 0.79; validation cohort: 0.77, 0.76 to 0.77) with excellent calibration (validation: calibration-in-the-large=0, slope=1.0). Patients with a score of at least 15 (n=4158, 19%) had a 62% mortality (positive predictive value 62%) compared with 1% mortality for those with a score of 3 or less (n=1650, 7%; negative predictive value 99%). Discriminatory performance was higher than 15 pre-existing risk stratification scores (area under the receiver operating characteristic curve range 0.61-0.76), with scores developed in other covid-19 cohorts often performing poorly (range 0.63-0.73). Conclusions: An easy-to-use risk stratification score has been developed and validated based on commonly available parameters at hospital presentation. The 4C Mortality Score outperformed existing scores, showed utility to directly inform clinical decision making, and can be used to stratify patients admitted to hospital with covid-19 into different management groups. The score should be further validated to determine its applicability in other populations. Study registration: ISRCTN66726260