Melanesian Ethnography and the Comparative Project of Anthropology: Reflection on Strathern's Analogical Approach. (March 2014)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Hirsch, Eric
• Editors: Copeman, Jacob; Street, Alice
• Is Part Of: Theory, culture & society. Volume 31:Number 2/3(2014:Mar./May)
• Page Start: 39
• Page End: 64
• Publication Date: 2014-03
• Subjects: gender -- intellectual property -- new reproductive technologies -- Papua New Guinea -- person -- relation -- the West; Social sciences -- Periodicals; 301.05
• DOI: 10.1177/0263276413510049
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0263-2764

Abstract

Melanesian ethnography has been a substantial and enduring presence in Strathern's comparative project of anthropology. The cornerstone of this project was The Gender of the Gift, where a model was established for demonstrating the analogies between Melanesian societies based on a system of common differences. The comparisons created in this work were centred on a real and radical divide between Melanesia and the West. Strathern's subsequent comparative work has examined the debates surrounding new social and technological forms in the West (e.g. new genetic and reproductive technologies) through drawing analogies with Melanesian social forms; she has simultaneously highlighted the limits of these comparisons. Her intention in this comparative project has been to expand the range of concepts and language used to understand western social and technological innovations that potentially affect the world at large, so that debate is not simply circumscribed by western preoccupations and concerns. As mediated through the analysis of Strathern and the other Melanesian anthropologists she draws on, the voices and interests of non-westerners can potentially inform and even reform the grounds of such deliberations.