Which predictive uncertainty to resolve? Value of information sensitivity analysis for environmental decision models. (December 2022)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Haag, Fridolin; Miñarro, Sara; Chennu, Arjun
• Is Part Of: Environmental modelling & software. Volume 158(2022)
• Publication Date: 2022-12
• Subjects: Sensitivity analysis -- Multi-criteria decision analysis -- Uncertainty -- Agent-based modeling -- Coral reef management; Environmental monitoring -- Computer programs -- Periodicals; Ecology -- Computer simulation -- Periodicals; Digital computer simulation -- Periodicals; Computer software -- Periodicals; Environmental Monitoring -- Periodicals; Computer Simulation -- Periodicals; Environnement -- Surveillance -- Logiciels -- Périodiques; Écologie -- Simulation, Méthodes de -- Périodiques; Simulation par ordinateur -- Périodiques; Logiciels -- Périodiques; Computer software; Digital computer simulation; Ecology -- Computer simulation; Environmental monitoring -- Computer programs; Periodicals; Electronic journals; 363.70015118
• DOI: 10.1016/j.envsoft.2022.105552
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1364-8152

Abstract

Abstract: Uncertainties in environmental decisions are large, but resolving them is costly. We provide a framework for value of information (VoI) analysis to identify key predictive uncertainties in a decision model. The approach addresses characteristics that complicate this analysis in environmental management: dependencies in the probability distributions of predictions, trade-offs between multiple objectives, and divergent stakeholder perspectives. For a coral reef fisheries case, we predict ecosystem and fisheries trajectories given different management alternatives with an agent-based model. We evaluate the uncertain predictions with preference models based on utility theory to find optimal alternatives for stakeholders. Using the expected value of partially perfect information (EVPPI), we measure how relevant resolving uncertainty for various decision attributes is. The VoI depends on the stakeholder preferences, but not directly on the width of an attribute's probability distribution. Our approach helps reduce costs in structured decision-making processes by prioritizing data collection efforts. Graphical abstract: Highlights: We investigate decision sensitivity in a coral reef management case. The framework considers ecological and economic consequences of management alternatives. Multiple stakeholders with divergent perspectives are considered. With value of information analysis we provide a ranking of key uncertainties. Our analysis supports the prioritization of future data collection efforts.