Accounting for Transport Error in Inversions: An Urban Synthetic Data Experiment. Issue 7 (9th July 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Ghosh, Subhomoy; Mueller, Kimberly; Prasad, Kuldeep; Whetstone, James
• Is Part Of: Earth and space science. Volume 8:Issue 7(2021)
• Page Start: n/a
• Page End: n/a
• Publication Date: 2021-07-09
• Subjects: error covariance -- regularization -- inversion -- Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter -- green house gases; Space sciences -- Periodicals; Geophysics -- Periodicals; 500.5
• DOI: 10.1029/2020EA001272
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2333-5084

Abstract

Abstract: We present and discuss the use of a high‐dimensional computational method for atmospheric inversions that incorporates the space‐time structure of transport and dispersion errors. In urban environments, transport and dispersion errors are largely the result of our inability to capture the true underlying transport of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions to observational sites. Motivated by the impact of transport model error on estimates of fluxes of GHGs using in situ tower‐based mole‐fraction observations, we specifically address the need to characterize transport error structures in high‐resolution large‐scale inversion models. We do this using parametric covariance functions combined with shrinkage‐based regularization methods within an Ensemble Transform Kalman Filter inversion setup. We devise a synthetic data experiment to compare the impact of transport and dispersion error component of the model‐data mismatch covariance choices on flux retrievals and study the robustness of the method with respect to fewer observational constraints. We demonstrate the analysis in the context of inferring CO2 fluxes starting with a hypothesized prior in the Washington D.C. /Baltimore area constrained by a synthetic set of tower‐based CO2 measurements within an observing system simulation experiment framework. This study demonstrates the ability of these simple covariance structures to substantially improve the estimation of fluxes over standard covariance models in flux estimation from urban regions. Plain Language Summary: Top‐down inversion approaches use atmospheric observations of greenhouse gases (GHG) to trace back emissions using atmospheric transport and dispersion models. Due to the high‐resolution, complex meteorology and topography of urban‐scale, transport and dispersion models are never accurate and the errors are correlated in space and time. It is therefore important to properly account for that in atmospheric inversions that estimate GHG emissions in urban regions. This study proposes multiple methods to characterize correlated error covariance matrices that demonstrate better performance than ubiquitous choices in a synthetic data experiment. These simple data‐adaptive covariance structures perform better than standard parametric models in both recovering total fluxes and their spatial distributions. Key Points: Urban‐scale transport errors are correlated in space and time, which should be included in atmospheric inversions that estimate greenhouse gas emissions In a synthetic data study, multiple methods to characterize correlated errors with model‐data covariance matrices demonstrate a better performance Overall, dynamically adaptive covariance structures perform better than standard parametric models in both recovering total fluxes and their spatial distributions