Characteristics of Precedent: The Case Law of the European Court of Justice in Three Dimensions. Issue 5 (6th October 2015)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Derlén, Mattias; Lindholm, Johan
• Is Part Of: German law journal. Volume 16:Issue 5(2015)
• Page Start: 1073
• Page End: 1098
• Publication Date: 2015-10-06
• Subjects: Law -- Germany -- Periodicals; Law -- Europe -- Periodicals; Comparative law -- Periodicals; International law -- Periodicals; jurisprudence; 349.4
• DOI: 10.1017/S2071832200021040
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2071-8322

Abstract

Abstract: The case law of the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) is one of the most important sources of European Union law. However, case law's role in EU law is not uniform. By empirically studying how the Court uses its own case law as a source of law, we explore the correlation between, on the one hand, the characteristics of a CJEU case—type of action, actors involved, and area of law—and, on the other hand, the judgment's "embeddedness" in previous case law and value as a precedent in subsequent cases. Using this approach, we test, confirm, and debunk existing scholarship concerning the role of CJEU case law as a source of EU law. We offer the following conclusions: that CJEU case law cannot be treated as a single entity; that only a limited number of factors reliably affect a judgment's persuasive or precedential power; that the Court's use of its own case law as a source of law is particularly limited in successful infringement proceedings; that case law is particularly important in preliminary references—especially those concerning fundamental freedoms and competition law; and that initiating Member State and the number of observations affects the behavior of the Court.