Attribute dependency graphs: modelling cause and effect in systems design. (26th October 2022)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Rötzer, Sebastian; Schweigert-Recksiek, Sebastian; Thoma, Dominik; Zimmermann, Markus
• Is Part Of: Design science. Volume 8(2022)
• Publication Date: 2022-10-26
• Subjects: Causality -- Complexity -- Dependency modeling -- Systems design -- Product design; Design -- Research -- Periodicals; New products -- Management -- Periodicals; Design; Design -- Research; Electronic journals; Periodicals; 658.5752
• DOI: 10.1017/dsj.2022.20
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2053-4701

Abstract

Abstract: Complexity in product design increases with little understanding of cause and effect. As a consequence, the impact of design decisions (or changes) on the product is difficult to predict and control. This article presents a model of cause and effect for design decisions that avoid circular dependencies: the so-called attribute dependency graph (ADG) models complex system behaviour and properties, and increases transparency by carefully distinguishing between what is realised and what is required. An ADG is a polyhierarchy, with design variables (directly controllable) at the bottom, quantities of interest (not directly controllable) on the top, and intermediate attributes. The dependencies represent causality in a simple sense: assigning values to design variables, representing the cause, will determine the values of the dependent attributes, representing the effect. ADGs do not account for what is required, but for what effects emerge by design activity. A set of rules makes them independent of designers' views. They provide the structure for so-called INUS conditions, that is, insufficient but necessary parts of unnecessary but sufficient conditions that can be used for requirement development. The modelling approach is applied to one simple synthetic and then to two real-world design problems, the design of a water hose box and a passenger vehicle.