Complexities in interpreting chironomid-based temperature reconstructions over the Holocene from a lake in Western Ireland. (15th October 2019)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: McKeown, Michelle M.; Caseldine, Chris J.; Thompson, Gareth; Swindles, Graeme T.; Ivanovic, Ruza F.; Roland, Thomas P.; Valdes, Paul J.; Potito, Aaron P.
• Is Part Of: Quaternary science reviews. Volume 222(2019)
• Publication Date: 2019-10-15
• Subjects: Holocene -- Palaeoclimatology -- Palaeolimnology -- Ireland -- Chironomidae -- Functional traits -- Pollen -- Climate models; Geology, Stratigraphic -- Quaternary -- Periodicals; Stratigraphie -- Quaternaire -- Périodiques; 551.79
• DOI: 10.1016/j.quascirev.2019.105908
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0277-3791

Abstract

Abstract: Investigation of Holocene climate variability remains challenging. This is largely due to chronological uncertainties and complexities associated with proxies and their relationship with climatic drivers. Pertinent questions still exist regarding the Holocene climate in Ireland, particularly in the early Holocene. We present a mean July air temperature reconstruction based on fossil chironomidae (non-biting midge flies), along with an assessment of chironomid functional traits from five guilds (based on their feeding habits) from Lough Nakeeroge, a small glacial lake in western Ireland. These records span the early to late Holocene (c. 10, 000–1500 cal yr BP). The chironomid record is supplemented with pollen data to determine landscape vegetation dynamics, and compared to climate model simulations of the same period. As reliable models are essential for robust analysis of long-term climate change, we critically assess the value of the chironomid transfer function and explore the use of chironomid functional traits to infer past climate variability. While this study demonstrates the complexities of chironomid-based temperature reconstruction in Irish lakes, it endeavours to i) disentangle a complicated Holocene climate history through the exploration of other long-term Holocene records from the island; and ii) improve our understanding of environmental responses to climate variability in Ireland. The findings of this study suggest that the interpretation of chironomid-based temperature transfer functions can be challenging. However, our results demonstrate the influence of climate on the functioning of lake ecosystems over the Holocene, with the promising performance of the collector-filterer feeding guild as a palaeothermometer. Highlights: There is a connection between chironomid functional traits, expressed through feeding guilds, and simulated annual air temperature. The chironomid July air temperature transfer function from Lough Nakeeroge is not solely reconstructing air temperature through the Holocene. Several important Holocene climate phases and events can be identified from the Irish palaeoclimate records. There is a clear contradiction between the proxy records and climate hindcast models over the mid-to late Holocene.