Discrepancy between disability and reported well-being after traumatic brain injury. Issue 7 (10th May 2022)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Retel Helmrich, Isabel Rosalie Arianne; van Klaveren, David; Andelic, Nada; Lingsma, Hester; Maas, Andrew; Menon, David; Polinder, Suzanne; Røe, Cecilie; Steyerberg, Ewout W; Van Veen, Ernest; Wilson, Lindsay
• Other Names: author non-byline.; Åkerlund Cecilia author non-byline.; Amrein Krisztina author non-byline.; Andelic Nada author non-byline.; Andreassen Lasse author non-byline.; Anke Audny author non-byline.; Antoni Anna author non-byline.; Audibert Gérard author non-byline.; Azouvi Philippe author non-byline.; Azzolini Maria Luisa author non-byline.; Bartels Ronald author non-byline.; Barzó Pál author non-byline.; Beauvais Romuald author non-byline.; Beer Ronny author non-byline.; Bellander Bo-Michael author non-byline.; Belli Antonio author non-byline.; Benali Habib author non-byline.; Berardino Maurizio author non-byline.; Beretta Luigi author non-byline.; Blaabjerg Morten author non-byline.; Bragge Peter author non-byline.; Brazinova Alexandra author non-byline.; Brinck Vibeke author non-byline.; Brooker Joanne author non-byline.; Brorsson Camilla author non-byline.; Buki Andras author non-byline.; Bullinger Monika author non-byline.; Cabeleira Manuel author non-byline.; Caccioppola Alessio author non-byline.; Calappi Emiliana author non-byline.; Calvi Maria Rosa author non-byline.; Cameron Peter author non-byline.; Lozano Guillermo Carbayo author non-byline.; Carbonara Marco author non-byline.; Cavallo Simona author non-byline.; Chevallard Giorgio author non-byline.; Chieregato Arturo author non-byline.; Citerio Giuseppe author non-byline.; Clusmann Hans author non-byline.; Coburn Mark author non-byline.; Coles Jonathan author non-byline.; Cooper Jamie D author non-byline.; Correia Marta author non-byline.; Čović Amra author non-byline.; Curry Nicola author non-byline.; Czeiter Endre author non-byline.; Czosnyka Marek author non-byline.; Dahyot‑Fizelier Claire author non-byline.; Dark Paul author non-byline.; Dawes Helen author non-byline.; Keyser Véronique De author non-byline.; Degos Vincent author non-byline.; Corte Francesco Della author non-byline.; Boogert Hugo den author non-byline.; Depreitere Bart author non-byline.; Đilvesi Đula author non-byline.; Dixit Abhishek author non-byline.; Donoghue Emma author non-byline.; Dreier Jens author non-byline.; Dulière Guy‑Loup author non-byline.; Ercole Ari author non-byline.; Esser Patrick author non-byline.; Ezer Erzsébet author non-byline.; Fabricius Martin author non-byline.; Feigin Valery L author non-byline.; Foks Kelly author non-byline.; Frisvold Shirin author non-byline.; Furmanov Alex author non-byline.; Gagliardo Pablo author non-byline.; Galanaud Damien author non-byline.; Gantner Dashiell author non-byline.; Gao Guoyi author non-byline.; George Pradeep author non-byline.; Ghuysen Alexandre author non-byline.; Giga Lelde author non-byline.; Glocker Ben author non-byline.; Golubovic Jagos author non-byline.; Gomez Pedro author non-byline.; Gratz Johannes author non-byline.; Gravesteijn Benjamin author non-byline.; Grossi Francesca author non-byline.; Gruen Russell L author non-byline.; Gupta Deepak author non-byline.; Haagsma Juanita A author non-byline.; Haitsma Iain author non-byline.; Helbok Raimund author non-byline.; Helseth Eirik author non-byline.; Horton Lindsay author non-byline.; Huijben Jilske author non-byline.; Hutchinson Peter J author non-byline.; Jacobs Bram author non-byline.; Jankowski Stefan author non-byline.; Jarrett Mike author non-byline.; Jiang Ji‑yao author non-byline.; Johnson Faye author non-byline.; Jones Kelly author non-byline.; Karan Mladen author non-byline.; Kolias Angelos G author non-byline.; Kompanje Erwin author non-byline.; Kondziella Daniel author non-byline.; Kornaropoulos Evgenios author non-byline.; Koskinen Lars‑Owe author non-byline.; Kovács Noémi author non-byline.; Kowark Ana author non-byline.; Lagares Alfonso author non-byline.; Lanyon Linda author non-byline.; Laureys Steven author non-byline.; Lecky Fiona author non-byline.; Ledoux Didier author non-byline.; Lefering Rolf author non-byline.; Legrand Valerie author non-byline.; Lejeune Aurelie author non-byline.; Levi Leon author non-byline.; Lightfoot Roger author non-byline.; Lingsma Hester author non-byline.; Maas Andrew IR author non-byline.; Castaño‑León Ana M author non-byline.; Maegele Marc author non-byline.; Majdan Marek author non-byline.; Manara Alex author non-byline.; Manley Geoffrey author non-byline.; Martino Costanza author non-byline.; Maréchal Hugues author non-byline.; Mattern Julia author non-byline.; McMahon Catherine author non-byline.; Melegh Béla author non-byline.; Menon David author non-byline.; Menovsky Tomas author non-byline.; Mikolic Ana author non-byline.; Misset Benoit author non-byline.; Muraleedharan Visakh author non-byline.; Murray Lynnette author non-byline.; Negru Ancuta author non-byline.; Nelson David author non-byline.; Newcombe Virginia author non-byline.; Nieboer Daan author non-byline.; Nyirádi József author non-byline.; Olubukola Otesile author non-byline.; Oresic Matej author non-byline.; Ortolano Fabrizio author non-byline.; Palotie Aarno author non-byline.; Parizel Paul M author non-byline.; Payen Jean‑François author non-byline.; Perera Natascha author non-byline.; Perlbarg Vincent author non-byline.; Persona Paolo author non-byline.; Peul Wilco author non-byline.; Piippo-Karjalainen Anna author non-byline.; Pirinen Matti author non-byline.; Ples Horia author non-byline.; Polinder Suzanne author non-byline.; Pomposo Inigo author non-byline.; Posti Jussi P author non-byline.; Puybasset Louis author non-byline.; Radoi Andreea author non-byline.; Ragauskas Arminas author non-byline.; Raj Rahul author non-byline.; Rambadagalla Malinka author non-byline.; Rhodes Jonathan author non-byline.; Richardson Sylvia author non-byline.; Richter Sophie author non-byline.; Ripatti Samuli author non-byline.; Rocka Saulius author non-byline.; Roe Cecilie author non-byline.; Roise Olav author non-byline.; Rosand Jonathan author non-byline.; Rosenfeld Jeffrey V author non-byline.; Rosenlund Christina author non-byline.; Rosenthal Guy author non-byline.; Rossaint Rolf author non-byline.; Rossi Sandra author non-byline.; Rueckert Daniel author non-byline.; Rusnák Martin author non-byline.; Sahuquillo Juan author non-byline.; Sakowitz Oliver author non-byline.; Sanchez‑Porras Renan author non-byline.; Sandor Janos author non-byline.; Schäfer Nadine author non-byline.; Schmidt Silke author non-byline.; Schoechl Herbert author non-byline.; Schoonman Guus author non-byline.; Schou Rico Frederik author non-byline.; Schwendenwein Elisabeth author non-byline.; Sewalt Charlie author non-byline.; Skandsen Toril author non-byline.; Smielewski Peter author non-byline.; Sorinola Abayomi author non-byline.; Stamatakis Emmanuel author non-byline.; Stanworth Simon author non-byline.; Stevens Robert author non-byline.; Stewart William author non-byline.; Steyerberg Ewout W author non-byline.; Stocchetti Nino author non-byline.; Sundström Nina author non-byline.; Takala Riikka author non-byline.; Tamás Viktória author non-byline.; Tamosuitis Tomas author non-byline.; Taylor Mark Steven author non-byline.; Ao Braden Te author non-byline.; Tenovuo Olli author non-byline.; Theadom Alice author non-byline.; Thomas Matt author non-byline.; Tibboel Dick author non-byline.; Timmers Marjolein author non-byline.; Tolias Christos author non-byline.; Trapani Tony author non-byline.; Tudora Cristina Maria author non-byline.; Unterberg Andreas author non-byline.; Vajkoczy Peter author non-byline.; Vallance Shirley author non-byline.; Valeinis Egils author non-byline.; Vámos Zoltán author non-byline.; Jagt Mathieu van der author non-byline.; Steen Gregory Van der author non-byline.; Naalt Joukje van der author non-byline.; Dijck Jeroen van author non-byline.; Essen Thomas A van author non-byline.; Hecke Wim Van author non-byline.; Heugten Caroline van author non-byline.; Praag Dominique Van author non-byline.; Vyvere Thijs Vande author non-byline.; Wijk Roel P J van author non-byline.; Vargiolu Alessia author non-byline.; Vega Emmanuel author non-byline.; Velt Kimberley author non-byline.; Verheyden Jan author non-byline.; Vespa Paul M author non-byline.; Vik Anne author non-byline.; Vilcinis Rimantas author non-byline.; Volovici Victor author non-byline.; Steinbüchel Nicole von author non-byline.; Voormolen Daphne author non-byline.; Vulekovic Petar author non-byline.; Wang Kevin KW author non-byline.; Wiegers Eveline author non-byline.; Williams Guy author non-byline.; Wilson Lindsay author non-byline.; Winzeck Stefan author non-byline.; Wolf Stefan author non-byline.; Yang Zhihui author non-byline.; Ylén Peter author non-byline.; Younsi Alexander author non-byline.; Zeiler Frederick A author non-byline.; Zelinkova Veronika author non-byline.; Ziverte Agate author non-byline.; Zoerle Tommaso author non-byline.;
• Is Part Of: Journal of neurology, neurosurgery and psychiatry. Volume 93:Issue 7(2022)
• Page Start: 785
• Page End: 796
• Publication Date: 2022-05-10
• Subjects: TRAUMATIC BRAIN INJURY -- QUALITY OF LIFE -- NEUROPSYCHOLOGY; Neurology -- Periodicals; Nervous system -- Surgery -- Periodicals; Psychiatry -- Periodicals; 616.8
• DOI: 10.1136/jnnp-2021-326615
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0022-3050

Abstract

Abstract : Background: Following traumatic brain injury (TBI), the clinical focus is often on disability. However, patients' perceptions of well-being can be discordant with their disability level, referred to as the 'disability paradox'. We aimed to examine the relationship between disability and health-related quality of life (HRQoL) following TBI, while taking variation in personal, injury-related and environment factors into account. Methods: We used data from the Collaborative European NeuroTrauma Effectiveness Research in Traumatic Brain Injury study. Disability was assessed 6 months post-injury by the Glasgow Outcome Scale-Extended (GOSE). HRQoL was assessed by the SF-12v2 physical and mental component summary scores and the Quality of Life after Traumatic Brain Injury overall scale. We examined mean total and domain HRQoL scores by GOSE. We quantified variance in HRQoL explained by GOSE, personal, injury-related and environment factors with multivariable regression. Results: Six-month outcome assessments were completed in 2075 patients, of whom 78% had mild TBI (Glasgow Coma Scale 13–15). Patients with severe disability had higher HRQoL than expected on the basis of GOSE alone, particularly after mild TBI. Up to 50% of patients with severe disability reported HRQoL scores within the normative range. GOSE, personal, injury-related and environment factors explained a limited amount of variance in HRQoL (up to 29%). Conclusion: Contrary to the idea that discrepancies are unusual, many patients with poor functional outcomes reported well-being that was at or above the boundary considered satisfactory for the normative sample. These findings challenge the idea that satisfactory HRQoL in patients with disability should be described as 'paradoxical' and question common views of what constitutes 'unfavourable' outcome.