Liver transplantation for hepatocellular carcinoma: impact of expansion criteria in a multicenter cohort study from a high waitlist mortality region. (7th January 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Piñero, Federico; Anders, Margarita; Boin, Ilka F.; Chagas, Aline; Quiñonez, Emilio; Marciano, Sebastián; Vilatobá, Mario; Santos, Luisa; Hoyos Duque, Sergio; Lima, Agnaldo Soares; Menendez, Josemaría; Padilla, Martín; Poniachik, Jaime; Zapata, Rodrigo; Soza, Alejandro; Maraschio, Martín; Chong Menéndez, Ricardo; Muñoz, Linda; Arufe, Diego; Figueroa, Rodrigo; de Ataide, Elaine Cristina; Maccali, Claudia; Vergara Sandoval, Rodrigo; Bermudez, Carla; Podesta, Luis G.; McCormack, Lucas; Varón, Adriana; Gadano, Adrián; Mattera, Juan; Villamil, Federico; Rubinstein, Fernando; Carrilho, Flair; Silva, Marcelo;
• Is Part Of: Transplant international. Volume 34:Number 1(2021)
• Page Start: 97
• Page End: 109
• Publication Date: 2021-01-07
• Subjects: allocation -- hepatocellular carcinoma -- liver transplantation -- selection; Transplantation of organs, tissues, etc -- Periodicals; 617.95405
• DOI: 10.1111/tri.13767
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0934-0874

Abstract

Summary: This study aimed to compare liver transplantation (LT) outcomes and evaluate the potential rise in numbers of LT candidates with hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) of different allocation policies in a high waitlist mortality region. Three policies were applied in two Latin American cohorts (1085 HCC transplanted patients and 917 listed patients for HCC): (i) Milan criteria with expansion according to UCSF downstaging (UCSF‐DS), (ii) the AFP score, and (iii) restrictive policy or Double Eligibility Criteria (DEC; within Milan + AFP score ≤2). Increase in HCC patient numbers was evaluated in an Argentinian prospective validation set (INCUCAI; NCT03775863). Expansion criteria in policy A showed that UCSF‐DS [28.4% (CI 12.8–56.2)] or "all‐comers" [32.9% (CI 11.9–71.3)] had higher 5‐year recurrence rates compared to Milan, with 10.9% increase in HCC patients for LT. The policy B showed lower recurrence rates for AFP scores ≤2 points, even expanding beyond Milan criteria, with a 3.3% increase. Patients within DEC had lower 5‐year recurrence rates compared with those beyond DEC [13.3% (CI 10.1–17.3) vs 24.2% (CI 17.4–33.1; P = 0.0006], without significant HCC expansion. In conclusion, although the application of a stricter policy may optimize the selection process, this restrictive policy may lead to ethical concerns in organ allocation (NCT03775863).