Oh, the places you will grow: Intraspecific latitudinal clines in butterfly size suggest a phylogenetic signal. Issue 5 (19th May 2022)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Merwin, Andrew C.; Hilliard, Justin; Larsen, Ashley; Lasken, Andrew G.; Johnson, Icesstrená
• Is Part Of: Ecology and evolution. Volume 12:Issue 5(2022)
• Page Start: n/a
• Page End: n/a
• Publication Date: 2022-05-19
• Subjects: Bergmann's Rule -- latitudinal clines -- Lycaenidae -- Riodinidae -- host plant nitrogen; Ecology -- Periodicals; Evolution -- Periodicals; 577.05
• DOI: 10.1002/ece3.8913
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2045-7758

Abstract

Abstract: Within an animal species, the body sizes of individuals at higher latitudes are often different from individuals at lower latitudes. For homeothermic species that maintain a relatively constant body temperature, such as mammals and birds, individuals at higher latitudes tend to be larger. For ectothermic species, such as insects, that do not retain their own body heat and which often do not maintain a relatively constant body temperature, patterns of body size with latitude are highly variable. This has led some authors to contend that patterns in even closely related species cannot be expected to be similar. Indeed, to our knowledge, no studies of invertebrates have found that more closely related species have more similar relationships between body size and latitude. Further, no studies have investigated the potential influence of diet quality on interspecific differences in these clines. We measured wing lengths of specimens (N = 1753) in eight lycaenid butterfly species and one species of the sister family, Riodinidae to determine if more closely related species have similar latitudinal trends. We also estimated the mean nitrogen content of caterpillars' hosts to investigate whether this often‐limiting nutrient influences the strength and direction of latitudinal clines in body size. We found that four species are significantly smaller at higher latitudes, an additional species is marginally smaller at higher latitudes ( p < .06), and four species had no significant relationship with latitude. We also found a strong phylogenetic signal for latitudinal clines in body size among our species, which indicates that some closely related species may have similar clines. However, the strength and direction of these clines did not depend on the estimated nitrogen content of caterpillars' hosts. Our results indicate that mean nitrogen content of hosts may not be an important driver in latitudinal clines but that phylogenetic relationships among species should be accounted for when exploring other potential drivers of body‐size clines in invertebrate species. Abstract : Latitudinal gradients in invertebrate body size vary widely. Yet, in our study we found that more closely related butterfly species have more similar latitudinal gradients. This research suggests a species‐level inheritance for sensitivity to factors associated with latitude and underscores the necessity of accounting for relatedness among species when attempting to use comparative approaches to investigate mechanisms underlying latitudinal trends in invertebrate body‐size.