Anomalous Phylogenetic Behavior of Ribosomal Proteins in Metagenome-Assembled Asgard Archaea. (18th November 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Garg, Sriram G; Kapust, Nils; Lin, Weili; Knopp, Michael; Tria, Fernando D K; Nelson-Sathi, Shijulal; Gould, Sven B; Fan, Lu; Zhu, Ruixin; Zhang, Chuanlun; Martin, William F
• Editors: Rebecca, Zufall
• Is Part Of: Genome biology and evolution. Volume 13:Number 1(2021)
• Publication Date: 2020-11-18
• Subjects: metagenomics -- binning -- eukaryogenesis -- phylogenetics -- asgard archaea -- candidate phylum radiation (CPR); Genomics -- Periodicals; Genes -- Periodicals; 572.8605
• DOI: 10.1093/gbe/evaa238
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1759-6653

Abstract

Abstract: Metagenomic studies permit the exploration of microbial diversity in a defined habitat, and binning procedures enable phylogenomic analyses, taxon description, and even phenotypic characterizations in the absence of morphological evidence. Such lineages include asgard archaea, which were initially reported to represent archaea with eukaryotic cell complexity, although the first images of such an archaeon show simple cells with prokaryotic characteristics. However, these metagenome-assembled genomes (MAGs) might suffer from data quality problems not encountered in sequences from cultured organisms due to two common analytical procedures of bioinformatics: assembly of metagenomic sequences and binning of assembled sequences on the basis of innate sequence properties and abundance across samples. Consequently, genomic sequences of distantly related taxa, or domains, can in principle be assigned to the same MAG and result in chimeric sequences. The impacts of low-quality or chimeric MAGs on phylogenomic and metabolic prediction remain unknown. Debates that asgard archaeal data are contaminated with eukaryotic sequences are overshadowed by the lack of evidence indicating that individual asgard MAGs stem from the same chromosome. Here, we show that universal proteins including ribosomal proteins of asgard archaeal MAGs fail to meet the basic phylogenetic criterion fulfilled by genome sequences of cultured archaea investigated to date: These proteins do not share common evolutionary histories to the same extent as pure culture genomes do, pointing to a chimeric nature of asgard archaeal MAGs. Our analysis suggests that some asgard archaeal MAGs represent unnatural constructs, genome-like patchworks of genes resulting from assembly and/or the binning process.