Formation Criteria for Hyporheic Anoxic Microzones: Assessing Interactions of Hydraulics, Nutrients, and Biofilms. Issue 3 (25th February 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Roy Chowdhury, Sinchan; Zarnetske, Jay P.; Phanikumar, Mantha S.; Briggs, Martin A.; Day‐Lewis, Frederick D.; Singha, Kamini
• Is Part Of: Water resources research. Volume 56:Issue 3(2020)
• Page Start: no
• Page End: no
• Publication Date: 2020-02-25
• Subjects: hyporheic zone -- microzones -- anoxic -- biofilm -- computational modeling -- groundwater‐surface water interactions; Hydrology -- Periodicals; 333.91
• DOI: 10.1029/2019WR025971
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0043-1397

Abstract

Abstract: Recent experimental studies have detected the presence of anoxic microzones in hyporheic sediments. These microzones are small‐scale anoxic pores, embedded within oxygen‐rich porous media and can act as anaerobic reaction sites producing reduction compounds such as nitrous oxide, a potent greenhouse gas. Microbes are a key control on nutrient transformation in hyporheic sediment, but their associated biomass growth is also capable of altering hydraulic flux, leading to potential bioclogging. Here, we developed one of the first computational modeling approaches that combined hydraulics and microbial conditions to explore the continuous evolution of microzones in stream sediments. The model assessed stream and sediment conditions with different hydraulic flux (0.1–1.0 m/day Darcy flux), nutrient concentrations (O2 = 8 mg/L, OrgC = 20 mg/L, NO − 3 = 1.5–3 mg/L, and NH3 = 0.5–1 mg/L), and biomass scenarios (with and without). The model domain is a pore network model with random sized pore‐throat radii creating heterogeneous and anisotropic flow that is representative of a natural streambed composed of medium sand with a hydraulic conductivity of 0.8 m/day. Results from 30 day simulations indicate that hyporheic microzone formation will occur and microzone distributions are not simply controlled by residence time alone, rather by the complex interactions of hydraulic flux, nutrient concentrations, and biomass, with bioclogging having strong feedbacks on both hydraulics and nutrients. Under all conditions with biomass growth, anoxic microzones were unstable, perishing a few days after formation, because bioclogging primarily occurs near the influent (downwelling) area of the hyporheic zone. In turn, this bioclogging shifts transport conditions from advection‐dominated to diffusion‐dominated transport, removing all oxic regions in the hyporheic zone. Overall, results from the modeling show that anoxic microzones are likely to form under many hyporheic zone conditions, and be dynamic through space and time as they are dependent on both hydraulic flux and nutrient transport. Plain Language Summary: Recent experimental studies detected a paradox occurring in stream ecosystems: that there are small zones within saturated stream sediments whose properties and functions vastly differ from the majority of the surrounding stream sediment. These "microzones" are likely ubiquitous in stream sediments but very difficult to locate and sample due to their small size. Microzones are exciting because they might be a key to understanding a range of other confounding findings in stream research, such as why streams can remove more pollutants or produce more greenhouse gases than previously expected. Microzones often occur in locations where there is little to no oxygen, which can lead to varying outcomes for solutes, nutrients, and organisms. Despite their small size, we can start to get clues into microzone formation and function through modeling studies. Here we assess microzones by modeling complex, interacting physical and biological processes to see what conditions promote, suppress, or sustain microzones. We found microbial biology, often overlooked in stream sediment studies, plays a highly important role in microzone processes, especially by creating biomass that clogs sediments and prevents microzones from forming or functioning in the stream ecosystem. Key Points: Anoxic microzones are likely to form under many hyporheic zone conditions Modeled biofilm conditions inhibit the formation of stable, flow‐independent microzones in hyporheic sediments A balance between the hydraulics and nutrients was required in the model to maximize microzone formation and stability