A New Comprehensive Approach to Assess the Probability of Success of Development Programs Before Pivotal Trials. Issue 5 (13th December 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Hampson, Lisa V.; Holzhauer, Björn; Bornkamp, Björn; Kahn, Joseph; Lange, Markus R.; Luo, Wen‐Lin; Singh, Pritibha; Ballerstedt, Steffen; Cioppa, Giovanni Della
• Is Part Of: Clinical pharmacology & therapeutics. Volume 111:Issue 5(2022)
• Page Start: 1050
• Page End: 1060
• Publication Date: 2021-12-13
• Subjects: Pharmacology -- Periodicals; Therapeutics -- Periodicals; 615.5
• DOI: 10.1002/cpt.2488
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0009-9236

Abstract

Abstract : The point at which clinical development programs transition from early phase to pivotal trials is a critical milestone. Substantial uncertainty about the outcome of pivotal trials may remain even after seeing positive early phase data, and companies may need to make difficult prioritization decisions for their portfolio. The probability of success (PoS) of a program, a single number expressed as a percentage reflecting the multitude of risks that may influence the final program outcome, is a key decision‐making tool. Despite its importance, companies often rely on crude industry benchmarks that may be "adjusted" by experts based on undocumented criteria and which are typically misaligned with the definition of success used to drive commercial forecasts, leading to overly optimistic expected net present value calculations. We developed a new framework to assess the PoS of a program before pivotal trials begin. Our definition of success encompasses the successful outcome of pivotal trials, regulatory approval and meeting the requirements for market access as outlined in the target product profile. The proposed approach is organized in four steps and uses an innovative Bayesian approach to synthesize all relevant evidence. The new PoS framework is systematic and transparent. It will help organizations to make more informed decisions. In this paper, we outline the rationale and elaborate on the structure of the proposed framework, provide examples, and discuss the benefits and challenges associated with its adoption.