Targeted next‐generation sequencing of environmental DNA improves detection of invasive European green crab (Carcinus maenas). Issue 2 (24th November 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Westfall, Kristen Marie; Therriault, Thomas W.; Abbott, Cathryn L.
• Is Part Of: Environmental DNA. Volume 4:Issue 2(2022)
• Page Start: 440
• Page End: 452
• Publication Date: 2021-11-24
• Subjects: CPUE -- detection probability -- invasive species -- invertebrate -- marine eDNA -- qPCR; DNA -- Periodicals; Biology -- Periodicals; Microbial ecology -- Periodicals; Biology; DNA; Microbial ecology; Electronic journals; Periodicals; 572.86
• DOI: 10.1002/edn3.261
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2637-4943

Abstract

Abstract: In the northeast Pacific Ocean, there is high interest in developing eDNA‐based survey methods to aid management of invasive populations of European green crab ( Carcinus maenas ). Expected benefits are improved sensitivity for early detection of secondary spread and to assess the outcome of eradication efforts. A new eDNA‐based approach we term "targeted next‐generation sequencing (tNGS)" is introduced here and shown to improve detection relative to qPCR at sites with lower green crab CPUE values measured by trapping. DNA standards (gBlock) with starting molecule copies that were 10 to 100 times lower than the qPCR limit of detection returned significant numbers of sequencing reads, which in our field assessments translated to a 7%–10% increase in detection probability from tNGS relative to qPCR at sites with lower CPUE. We also found the number of sequencing reads from tNGS was significantly correlated with green crab CPUE whereas Ct values from qPCR were not. When sources of variation were partitioned for each assay, we found the difference between mean within‐site and mean between‐site variation was much larger and had non‐overlapping confidence intervals for tNGS relative to qPCR, suggesting the former may offer more power for detecting spatial variation in eDNA availability. Results presented here indicate this approach is suitable for species of known low abundances where a positive detection has high economic or environmental consequences, or for labs doing eDNA surveys for whom NGS‐based workflows are operationally more efficient than qPCR given its upward scalability. Any species with an existing qPCR assay can be easily tested with a tNGS assay using the approach presented here. We conclude with a discussion on the fitness for purpose of tNGS vs. qPCR for various applications and on how to best apply molecular surveys in management programs. Abstract : Here, we present the targeted next‐generation sequencing assay (tNGS) that shows improved sensitivity, compared with qPCR, for detecting green crab from eDNA when abundance is low. We found that the new tNGS assay is more powerful than qPCR for detecting differences in green crab density from eDNA. We expect this assay to be useful for research aimed at rare species, such as invasive or species‐at‐risk.