Cultural Similarities and Differences in Explaining Others' Behavior in 4- to 9-Year-Old Children From Three Cultural Contexts. (July 2022)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Jurkat, Solveig; Iza Simba, Nancy Beatriz; Hernández Chacón, Ledys; Itakura, Shoji; Kärtner, Joscha
• Is Part Of: Journal of cross-cultural psychology. Volume 53:Number 6(2022)
• Page Start: 659
• Page End: 682
• Publication Date: 2022-07
• Subjects: culture -- causal attribution -- social explanations -- child development; Ethnopsychology -- Periodicals; 155.805
• DOI: 10.1177/00220221221098423
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0022-0221

Abstract

Previous studies suggest that people from the Western hemisphere tend to explain others' behavior based on a person's traits and dispositions, while participants from non-Western cultural settings more likely refer to situational factors. From a developmental perspective, it has been suggested that culture-specific modes of explaining behavior gradually emerge during late childhood and adolescence. The present study explored whether traces of a corresponding culture-specific development can be found at earlier ages when using simplified assessments. In total, 438 children between 4 and 9 years old from Münster (urban Germany), Kyoto (urban Japan), and Cotacachi (rural Ecuador), were asked to explain positive and deviant behaviors of children depicted in simple picture-based vignettes. While more internal attributions were given in Münster than in Kyoto and Cotacachi children at 4 to 5 years old, these cultural differences disappeared as internal attributions significantly increased with age in Kyoto and Cotacachi but not Münster children. Analyzing children's explanations on a level of subcategories revealed more subtle cultural specificities. For example, when giving internal explanations, Cotacachi children focused on stable traits, while Münster children emphasized individual desires and Kyoto children highlighted more volatile aspects. Cross-cultural differences in children's social explanations could partially be explained by mothers' preference for autonomy-related socialization goals. Taken together, this study provides evidence for an earlier onset of internal explanations when they are culturally accentuated and further calls for a more nuanced approach to capture culture-specific meaning systems reflected in everyday social explanations.