The health and well-being impacts of a work integration social enterprise from a systems perspective. (20th May 2021) - Joyce, Andrew
Summary: Recent research has drawn upon the social determinants of health (SDH) framework to attempt to systematize the relationship between social enterprise and health. In this article, we adopt a realist evaluation approach to conceptualize social enterprises, and work integration social enterprises in particular, as 'complex interventions' that necessarily produce differential health outcomes for their beneficiaries, communities and staff. Drawing upon the findings from four social enterprises involving a range of methods including 93 semi-structured interviews with employees, managers and enterprise partners, together with participant observation, we demonstrate that these health outcomes are influenced by a limitless mix of complex and dynamic interactions between systems, settings, spaces, relationships and organizational and personal factors that cannot be distilled by questions of causality and attribution found in controlled trial designs. Given the increased policy focus on the potential of social enterprises to affect the SDH, this article seeks to respond to evidence gaps about the mechanisms and contexts through which social enterprises promote or constrain health outcomes, and thereby provide greater clarity about how research evidence can be used to support the social enterprise sector and policy development more broadly. Lay Summary: Work integration social enterprises (WISEs) are hybrid organizations that operate as businesses with a social purpose. WISEs focus on employment of people excluded from open employment, often as a result of discriminatory attitudes and practices of employers to people from minority groups and those experiencing disability or health-related problems. There is a lack of research on the ways in which a WISE could positively impact on individual health and well-being. We interviewed employees, managers and enterprise partners, together with participant observation, across four social enterprises to understand these dynamics. Through a number of strategies including flexible workplace structures, a culture of acceptance and support, encouragement to take risks and make mistakes and creative use of space, the participants described changes to health and well-being such as decreased symptoms of anxiety and depression, increased social connections, improved physical activity and increased confidence and self-esteem. Results show a mix of strategies combined with individually tailored support; this has implications for the type of research that is appropriate to understand these impacts. We conclude with suggestions on how future research could use complex research designs to understand how WISEs can influence health and well-being.