Do health insurers use target marketing as a tool for risk selection? Evidence from the Netherlands. Issue 2 (February 2022) - Stolper, Karel C.F.
Highlights: Dutch health insurers target both financially favourable and unfavourable consumer groups. Most marketing efforts are targeted at financially favourable groups. Only a minority of insurers' marketing efforts are targeted at care users. Insurers are not effectively stimulated as prudent buyers of care. Key to solving this problem is improvement of the risk equalisation system. Abstract: In health care systems based on managed competition, enrolees can choose between insurers who are positioned as prudent buyers of care on their behalf. To avoid risk selection, insurers are compensated through a system of risk equalisation. The Dutch system of risk equalisation is generally considered to be one of the most sophisticated in the world. Empirical evidence, however, shows there are still consumer segments that are profitable for insurers. To examine whether insurers use target marketing for attracting these segments, we assessed promotional material used by Dutch insurers during the switching season of 2019. Our findings provide preliminary evidence that large insurers with different brands primarily use their sub brands as strategic vehicles to improve their competitive positions by targeting these brands at financially favourable groups and price sensitive buyers. By contrast, the more visible main brands are targeted at a much broader spectrum of consumer groups to display the insurer's social character. Only a minority of insurers' marketing expressions are targeted at actual users of care. Despite continuous improvements in the risk equalisation system, on average this group is still unprofitable for insurers. From a health policy perspective, further improvements are key to motivate health insurers to target their efforts at improving care for the chronically ill and to eliminate incentives for risk selection.