"Reflection and soul searching": Negotiating nursing identity at the fault lines of palliative care and medical assistance in dying. (November 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Wright, David Kenneth; Chan, Lisa S.; Fishman, Jennifer R.; Macdonald, Mary Ellen
• Is Part Of: Social science & medicine. Volume 289(2021)
• Publication Date: 2021-11
• Subjects: Medical assistance in dying -- Euthanasia -- Palliative care -- Nursing -- Feminist ethics -- Qualitative research -- Canada; Social medicine -- Periodicals; Medical anthropology -- Periodicals; Public health -- Periodicals; Psychology -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals; Médecine sociale -- Périodiques; Anthropologie médicale -- Périodiques; Santé publique -- Périodiques; Psychologie -- Périodiques; Médecine -- Périodiques; Electronic journals; 362.105
• DOI: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2021.114366
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0277-9536

Abstract

Abstract: Authorities within the field of palliative care frequently espouse that assisted death is – and must remain – separate from palliative care. This fault line, between palliative care and assisted death, has important implications for how we enact end-of-life care, particularly in jurisdictions where assisted death is legal. And yet little is known about how direct-care clinicians providing palliative care navigate this demarcation in everyday practice. This qualitative study reports on semi-structured interviews with 22 palliative care nurses from across Canada, where assisted death was legalized in 2016. Although a minority of participants did express categorical opinions around the (non) legitimacy of assisted death as an ethical end-of-life care option, most engaged in an ongoing and sometimes painful process of questioning and self-examination. Their ethical reflections were more nuanced than simply dismissing MAiD as incompatible with palliative care philosophy; yet this idea of incompatibility weighed heavily as they reasoned through their experiences and questioned their own perspectives. Nurses described grappling with the finality of assisted death, which contradicts their belief in the telos of palliative care; when adequately resourced, palliative care should be available to support people to live well before death. At the same time, commitment to important palliative care values such as the non-abandonment of dying people and respecting peoples' individual end-of-life choices reveal the possibility of overlap between the ethos of assisted death and that of palliative care nursing. Drawing on scholarship in feminist ethics, our study sheds light on the moral identity work that assisted dying catalyzes amongst palliative care nurses. We highlight what is at stake for them as they navigate a delicate tension in responding ethically to patients whose suffering motivates an interest in assisted death, from within a wider professional collective that upholds a master narrative about the incompatibility of assisted death and palliative care. Highlights: Palliative care typically claims to be distinct from assisted death. Everyday nursing practice with patients seeking assisted death nuances this distinction. A feminist analysis invites reflection on how the ethics of palliative care and the ethics of assisted death might overlap. Abstract : I thought I knew death … and yet this felt profoundly different from the many deaths I had experienced – Beuthin and Bruce, 2019