Biofilms vs. cities and humans vs. aliens – a tale of reproducibility in biofilms. Issue 12 (December 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Azevedo, Nuno F.; Allkja, Jontana; Goeres, Darla M.
• Is Part Of: Trends in microbiology. Volume 29:Issue 12(2021)
• Page Start: 1062
• Page End: 1071
• Publication Date: 2021-12
• Subjects: biofilm -- reproducibility -- methods; Microbiology -- Periodicals; Infection -- Periodicals; Virulence (Microbiology) -- Periodicals; Infection -- Periodicals; Microbiology -- Periodicals; Virulence -- Periodicals; Microbiologie -- Périodiques; Infection -- Périodiques; Virulence (Microbiologie) -- Périodiques; Infection; Microbiology; Virulence (Microbiology); 579
• DOI: 10.1016/j.tim.2021.05.003
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0966-842X

Abstract

Abstract : Biofilms are complex and dynamic structures that include many more components than just viable cells. Therefore, the apparently simple goal of growing reproducible biofilms is often elusive. One of the challenges in defining reproducibility for biofilm research is that different research fields use a spectrum of parameters to define reproducibility for their particular application. For instance, is the researcher interested in achieving a similar population density, height of biofilm structures, or function of the biofilm in a certain ecosystem/industrial context? Within this article we categorize reproducibility into four different levels: level 1, no reproducibility; level 2, standard reproducibility; level 3, potential standard reproducibility; and level 4, total reproducibility. To better understand the need for these different levels of reproducibility, we expand on the 'cities of microbes' analogy for biofilms by imagining that a new civilization has reached the Earth's outskirts and starts studying the Earth's cities. This will provide a better sense of scale and illustrate how small details can impact profoundly on the growth and behavior of a biofilm and our understanding of reproducibility. Highlights: In recent decades the scientific community has started to appreciate that most microorganisms live in complex 3D structures composed of cells, polysaccharides, and other components such as proteins, extracellular (e)DNA, and lipids. These structures are commonly designated 'biofilms'. Similar to other areas of research, biofilm studies have been affected by a lack of reproducibility. In this article, we propose a new scheme on how to classify the level of reproducibility in biofilms. This consists of four different levels: level 1, no reproducibility; level 2, standard reproducibility; level 3, potential standard reproducibility; and level 4, total reproducibility. Some methods aim to improve reproducibility by focusing on biofilm growth reactors, while others focus on biofilm characterization methods. Moreover, initiatives such as minimum information guidelines and biofilm-centered databases offer alternative strategies to tackle the reproducibility problem. The path to total reproducibility is certainly complex, but novel experimental and computational strategies are bringing us closer to achieving this goal.