Thermal tolerance of cyprinids along an urban-rural gradient: Plasticity, repeatability and effects of swimming and temperature shock. (August 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Nelson, Jay A.; Rieger, Kelly J.; Gruber, Danielle; Cutler, Melinda; Buckner, Bailee; Oufiero, Christopher E.
• Is Part Of: Journal of thermal biology. Volume 100(2021)
• Publication Date: 2021-08
• Subjects: Thermal tolerance -- Plasticity -- Urbanization -- Cyprinid -- CTMax; Thermobiology -- Periodicals; Temperature -- Periodicals; Biology -- Periodicals; Thermobiologie -- Périodiques; Thermobiology; Periodicals; 571.46
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jtherbio.2021.103047
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0306-4565

Abstract

Abstract: Urbanization changes the thermal profile of streams in much the same way that climate change is predicted to with higher temperatures, more varied flow and rapid temperature pulses with precipitation events. Whether exceptional tolerance to these altered thermal conditions is a pre-requisite for a fish species to inhabit urban streams or if urbanization has changed the thermal physiology of those fish species that persist in urban streams is unknown, but could help predict the outcome of future climate disruption. To test whether residence in urban streams is associated with altered thermal tolerance, we compared thermal tolerance (CTMax ) and phenotypic plasticity of thermal tolerance (ΔCTMax /Δ acclimation temperature) in five populations of an urban-tolerant cyprinid, the blacknose dace ( Rhinichthys atratulus ), from multiple watersheds along an urban/rural gradient. Thermal tolerance of these stream fish was tested while swimming at 10 cm*s −1 but also in static water and after thermal shocks of 4°–6 °C simulating precipitation events. To test whether blacknose dace as a species has unusual thermal tolerance or thermal plasticity, we also compared two blacknose dace populations with two co-resident, co-familiars (creek chub ( Semotilus atromaculatus ) and rosyside dace ( Clinostomus funduloides ), that don't persist in urban streams at three different acclimation temperatures. Thermal tolerance of blacknose dace, as measured by a critical thermal maximum test (CTMax ), was independent of size and activity level, i.e. individuals had identical thermal tolerance whether swimming or resting and CTMax was significantly repeatable across two levels of activity. Although there was some variance among populations, blacknose dace from streams of varied urbanization generally exhibited comparable thermal tolerances, ability to acclimate to different temperatures and were unaffected by thermal shocks. Rosyside dace had significantly lower thermal tolerance than the other two species but plasticity of thermal tolerance was uniform across the three cyprinid species. Our conclusions are that exceptional thermal tolerance or ability to thermally acclimate are not pre-requisite characters for a given cyprinid species to survive in urban streams, nor has thermal tolerance undergone directional selection in this urban environment. Highlights: Thermal tolerance is significantly repeatable in a stream cyprinid. Thermal tolerance is identical in swimming and resting individuals. Exceptional thermal tolerance or plasticity is not required to occupy urban streams. Thermal tolerance or plasticity are not under directional selection in urban streams.