Hepa filter age evaluation and estimate of nominal lifetime in nuclear facilities. (September 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Barnett, J. Matthew; Schrank, Kobe R.; Bliss, Mary; Cooley, Scott K.
• Is Part Of: Progress in nuclear energy. Volume 139(2021)
• Publication Date: 2021-09
• Subjects: HEPA -- Filter -- Age -- Statistics -- Compliance; Nuclear energy -- Periodicals; Nuclear engineering -- Periodicals; 333.7924
• DOI: 10.1016/j.pnucene.2021.103881
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0149-1970

Abstract

Abstract: In 2020, PNNL completed a literature search for high-efficiency particulate air (HEPA) filter age information. HEPA filters are used in many operations to remove particulate matter from effluent exhaust streams. They are thought to degrade over time both during proper storage and during normal operational service; however, the rate at which the filters degrade remains unknown. This brings into question if age is an adequate indicator of HEPA filter performance. Data from six previous reports were obtained from the literature search and combined to create a data set of 1600 operating filters. Filter usage was identified from multiple facilities. The various types of filters (e.g., axial flow, self-contained, and standard 61 × 61 × 28 cm; and both separator and separatorless) reported were constructed to the requirements Section FC (HEPA Filters) or Section FK (Special HEPA Filters) of the American Society of Mechanical Engineers AG-1 code. Filters were presumed to have continuously met the operational criteria and in particular passed both annual efficiency tests and annual differential pressure measurements. The environmental conditions within the exhaust system were also assumed adequate for long-term filter operation. The data, by the nature of the reports, excludes rejected filters from quality assurance evaluations, intake, or installation testing. The collective data set shows over half of were operating past the recommended 10-year Department of Energy (DOE) lifetime. Data was evaluated for age lifetime using a linear trendline, survival function, probability functions, and failure rate; financial impacts were also addressed. This report supports the notion that HEPA filters can operate safely and efficiently under proper maintenance well past the 10-year lifetime established by DOE. Using the results of the four age evaluation approaches, they collectively point to the reasonableness of an operating HEPA filter lifetime of 20 years. The results are not necessarily definitive, but nevertheless, they are promising. The analysis provides reasonable assurance that when implemented using a graded approach with well-defined performance and operational requirements, extending the service life for HEPA filters beyond 10 years is low risk. Highlights: HEPA filter age and lifetime is evaluated based on historical records. A composite of methods show a 20-year HEPA lifetime is reasonable and low-risk. Regulatory compliance and a maintenance and operations program are necessary.