A semiparametric approach for item response function estimation to detect item misfit. (17th December 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Köhler, Carmen; Robitzsch, Alexander; Fährmann, Katharina; von Davier, Matthias; Hartig, Johannes
• Is Part Of: British journal of mathematical & statistical psychology. Volume 74(2021)Supplement 1
• Page Start: 157
• Page End: 175
• Publication Date: 2020-12-17
• Subjects: item fit -- item response theory -- semiparametric estimation -- group lasso; Psychometrics -- Periodicals; Psychology -- Mathematical models -- Periodicals; Psychology -- Statistical methods -- Periodicals; 150.727
• DOI: 10.1111/bmsp.12224
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0007-1102

Abstract

Abstract : When scaling data using item response theory, valid statements based on the measurement model are only permissible if the model fits the data. Most item fit statistics used to assess the fit between observed item responses and the item responses predicted by the measurement model show significant weaknesses, such as the dependence of fit statistics on sample size and number of items. In order to assess the size of misfit and to thus use the fit statistic as an effect size, dependencies on properties of the data set are undesirable. The present study describes a new approach and empirically tests it for consistency. We developed an estimator of the distance between the predicted item response functions (IRFs) and the true IRFs by semiparametric adaptation of IRFs. For the semiparametric adaptation, the approach of extended basis functions due to Ramsay and Silverman (2005) is used. The IRF is defined as the sum of a linear term and a more flexible term constructed via basis function expansions. The group lasso method is applied as a regularization of the flexible term, and determines whether all parameters of the basis functions are fixed at zero or freely estimated. Thus, the method serves as a selection criterion for items that should be adjusted semiparametrically. The distance between the predicted and semiparametrically adjusted IRF of misfitting items can then be determined by describing the fitting items by the parametric form of the IRF and the misfitting items by the semiparametric approach. In a simulation study, we demonstrated that the proposed method delivers satisfactory results in large samples (i.e., N ≥ 1, 000).