We Can Make a Better Use of ORCID: Five Observed Misapplications. (31st December 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Baglioni, Miriam; Manghi, Paolo; Mannocci, Andrea; Bardi, Alessia
• Is Part Of: Data science journal. Volume 20(2021)
• Publication Date: 2021-12-31
• Subjects: ORCID -- Scholarly Communication -- Open Science -- Disambiguation -- Misapplication; Science -- Data processing -- Periodicals; Database management -- Periodicals; 502.85
• DOI: 10.5334/dsj-2021-038
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1683-1470

Abstract

Since 2012, the "Open Researcher and Contributor ID" organisation (ORCID) has been successfully running a worldwide registry, with the aim of "providing a unique, persistent identifier for individuals to use as they engage in research, scholarship, and innovation activities". Any service in the scholarly communication ecosystem (e.g., publishers, repositories, CRIS systems, etc.) can contribute to a non-ambiguous scholarly record by including, during metadata deposition, referrals to iDs in the ORCID registry. The OpenAIRE Research Graph is a scholarly knowledge graph that aggregates both records from the ORCID registry and publication records with ORCID referrals from publishers and repositories worldwide to yield research impact monitoring and Open Science statistics. Graph data analytics revealed "anomalies" due to ORCID registry "misapplications", caused by wrong ORCID referrals and misexploitation of the ORCID registry. Albeit these affect just a minority of ORCID records, they inevitably affect the quality of the ORCID infrastructure and may fuel the rise of detractors and scepticism about the service. In this paper, we classify and qualitatively document such misapplications, identifying five ORCID registrant-related and ORCID referral-related anomalies to raise awareness among ORCID users. We describe the current countermeasures taken by ORCID and, where applicable, provide recommendations. Finally, we elaborate on the importance of a community-steered Open Science infrastructure and the benefits this approach has brought and may bring to ORCID.