Genetic Diversity and Divergence among Bighorn Sheep from Reintroduced Herds in Washington and Idaho. Issue 6 (7th June 2021) - Barbosa, Soraia
ABSTRACT: Bighorn sheep ( Ovis canadensis ) populations in the western United States have undergone widespread declines and extirpations since the late nineteenth century as a consequence of introduced diseases, competition with livestock, and unregulated hunting. Washington, Idaho, USA, and British Columbia, Canada were historically thought to be occupied by 2 bighorn lineages or subspecies: Rocky Mountain ( O. c. canadensis ) and California ( O. c. californiana ). The putative California lineage was completely extirpated in the United States, and reintroductions to reestablish populations were sourced directly or indirectly from a single region in southern British Columbia. Restoration efforts have attempted to maintain the diversity and divergence of these 2 lineages, sometimes referred to as subspecies although taxonomic classifications have changed over time. In this study we describe genetic variation in a subset of native and reintroduced herds of California and Rocky Mountain bighorn sheep. We examined genetic diversity and divergence between bighorn sheep herds using 15 microsatellite loci, including 4 loci linked to genes involved in immune function. We analyzed 504 samples from reintroduced herds in Washington ( n = 10 California herds, n = 4 Rocky Mountain herds) and Idaho ( n = 5 California), and source herds in Oregon ( n = 1 Rocky Mountain) and British Columbia ( n = 5 California, 1 Rocky Mountain). Genetic structure reflected known reintroduction history, and geographic proximity also was associated with decreased genetic divergence. Herds in Washington and Idaho sourced from California bighorn sheep were less genetically diverse than those sourced from Rocky Mountain herds. Also, levels of relatedness within and across California herds were higher than in Rocky Mountain herds and similar to what would be expected for full and half siblings. Lower diversity and higher relatedness among California herds is a concern for long‐term fitness and likely related to past population bottlenecks, fewer source populations, and management history, such as entirely sourcing California herds from British Columbia. Genetic divergence of neutral loci between California and Rocky Mountain herds was greater than that of adaptive loci, potentially indicating that balancing selection has maintained similar genetic diversity across lineages in loci associated with immune and other adaptive functions. Thus, we recommend future reintroductions and augmentations should continue to use source populations from the appropriate California or Rocky Mountain lineage to avoid potential outbreeding depression and maintain possible adaptive differences. This could be accomplished by obtaining sheep from ≥1 source within the genetic lineage, while avoiding sourcing from admixed herds. Future work encompassing a broader geographic sampling of populations and a greater portion of the genome is necessary to better evaluate the degree to which contemporary divergence between lineages is associated with recent founder effects and genetic isolation or evolutionary adaptation. © 2021 The Wildlife Society : Reintroduced bighorn sheep herds in Washington and Idaho managed as California bighorn sheep were genetically distinct from reintroduced Rocky Mountain herds and showed lower overall genetic diversity and higher levels of relatedness. Adaptive genetic variation was higher than neutral variation in California and Rocky Mountain herds, suggesting balancing selection is playing a role in maintaining diversity. We recommend managing to maintain or increase genetic diversity in reintroduced California bighorn sheep populations in Idaho and Washington while protecting distinctiveness between lineages until the causes of genetic divergence are better understood.