Dung beetles show metabolic plasticity as pupae and smaller adult body size in response to increased temperature mean and variance. (May 2021)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Morgan Fleming, J.; Carter, Amanda W.; Sheldon, Kimberly S.
• Is Part Of: Journal of insect physiology. Volume 131(2021)
• Publication Date: 2021-05
• Subjects: Dung beetles -- Fitness -- Onthophagus taurus -- Thermal plasticity -- Fluctuation -- Metabolism -- Scarabaeinae; Insects -- Physiology -- Periodicals; Insectes -- Physiologie -- Périodiques; Insects -- Physiology; Periodicals; 571.157
• DOI: 10.1016/j.jinsphys.2021.104215
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0022-1910

Abstract

Graphical abstract: Highlights: Onthophagus taurus respond plastically to increased temperature mean and variance. Pupal metabolism was lowest in O. taurus in the warmest, most variable treatment. Adults were three times smaller when reared in the warmest, most variable treatment. A threshold of mean and variance triggered lower metabolism and smaller body sizes. Reduced metabolism may not overcome energetic costs of temperature changes. Abstract: Though organisms may use thermal plasticity to cope with novel temperature regimes, our understanding of plastic responses is limited. Research on thermal plasticity has traditionally focused on the response of organisms to shifts in mean temperatures. However, increased temperature variation can have a greater impact on organismal performance than mean temperature alone. In addition, thermal plasticity studies are often designed to investigate plasticity in response to more extreme temperatures despite the fact that organisms make physiological adjustments to diurnal temperature fluctuations that they experience. Using pupae of the dung beetle Onthophagus taurus, we investigated the potential for plasticity in response to increasing temperature mean and variance using thermal regimes that were well within the species critical thermal limits. We reared 40 beetles from egg to pupae (n = 20) or adults (n = 20) at one of nine incubation treatments, including all combinations of three mean temperatures (22, 24, 26 °C) and three amplitudes of fluctuation (±2, ±4, ±8 °C). To measure thermal plasticity of pupae, we quantified CO2 production across a range of temperatures (i.e., 15, 20, 25, and 30 °C) for 20 beetles per treatment. The relationship between CO2 production and temperature provides an estimate of energetic costs at a given temperature (i.e., using the intercept) and thermal sensitivity (i.e., using the slope). We reared the remaining O. taurus in each treatment (n = 20) to adulthood and then recorded mass (g) to determine body size, a proxy for fitness. Pupae exhibited thermal plasticity in response to the additive and interactive effects of temperature mean and variance. Pupae reared in the warmest and most variable treatment (26 ± 8 °C) showed the greatest decrease in overall metabolism compared to all other treatments, and adult beetles from this treatment (26 ± 8 °C) were also significantly smaller than adult beetles from any other treatment. We found that both temperature mean and variance contributed to thermal plasticity of pupae and had consequences for adult body size, a trait related to dung beetle fitness. Importantly, the temperatures we used in our treatments are not extreme and are likely well below the critical thermal maxima of the species, demonstrating that organisms can make adjustments to temperatures they experience across diurnal or seasonal timescales.