Reflection on modern methods: generalized linear models for prognosis and intervention—theory, practice and implications for machine learning. (7th May 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Arnold, Kellyn F; Davies, Vinny; de Kamps, Marc; Tennant, Peter W G; Mbotwa, John; Gilthorpe, Mark S
• Is Part Of: International journal of epidemiology. Volume 49:Number 6(2020)
• Page Start: 2074
• Page End: 2082
• Publication Date: 2020-05-07
• Subjects: Prediction -- causal inference -- generalized linear models -- directed acyclic graphs -- machine learning -- artificial intelligence; Epidemiology -- Periodicals; 614.4
• DOI: 10.1093/ije/dyaa049
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0300-5771

Abstract

Abstract: Prediction and causal explanation are fundamentally distinct tasks of data analysis. In health applications, this difference can be understood in terms of the difference between prognosis (prediction) and prevention/treatment (causal explanation). Nevertheless, these two concepts are often conflated in practice. We use the framework of generalized linear models (GLMs) to illustrate that predictive and causal queries require distinct processes for their application and subsequent interpretation of results. In particular, we identify five primary ways in which GLMs for prediction differ from GLMs for causal inference: (i) the covariates that should be considered for inclusion in (and possibly exclusion from) the model; (ii) how a suitable set of covariates to include in the model is determined; (iii) which covariates are ultimately selected and what functional form (i.e. parameterization) they take; (iv) how the model is evaluated; and (v) how the model is interpreted. We outline some of the potential consequences of failing to acknowledge and respect these differences, and additionally consider the implications for machine learning (ML) methods. We then conclude with three recommendations that we hope will help ensure that both prediction and causal modelling are used appropriately and to greatest effect in health research.