Constructing a crisis: The effect of resource curse discourse on extractive governance in Ghana. Issue 3 (July 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Johnson, McKenzie F.; Laurent, Rebecca L.; Kwao, Benjamin
• Is Part Of: Extractive industries and society. Volume 7:Issue 3(2020)
• Page Start: 965
• Page End: 974
• Publication Date: 2020-07
• Subjects: Gold -- Ghana -- Oil -- extractive governance -- resource curse; Mineral industries -- Periodicals; Gas industry -- Periodicals; Petroleum industry and trade -- Periodicals; 338.205
• DOI: 10.1016/j.exis.2020.04.013
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 2214-790X

Abstract

Highlights: We examine the effects of oil on Ghana's extractive governance landscape. Ghana's 2007 oil discovery prompted concern about the political resource curse. Resource curse discourse centered political attention on oil relative to gold. Solutions to resource curse overlook how gold drives instability in Ghana. Resource curse mischaracterizes and depoliticizes extractive violence. Abstract: Ghana's 2007 oil discovery prompted widespread concern about the "political resource curse." Ghanaian policymakers, in partnership with the international community, mobilized resource curse discourse to propel innovative reforms aimed at building institutional capacity, enhancing transparency, and promoting accountability. Ghana's urgent and decisive response to the problem of oil, however, highlighted its relative lack of resolve to address enduring mineral conflict. In this article, we employ fieldwork, event ethnography, and a content analysis of 1, 003 articles published in Ghana's Daily Graphic (2006-2012) to trace the discursive and material effects of oil on Ghana's extractive governance landscape. We argue that global discourse around oil grounded in resource curse centered Ghana's political attention on oil relative to conventional minerals like gold and reinforced modes of extractive governance that overlook longstanding violence around gold extraction. Our research demonstrates the continued power of resource curse discourse to construct a model of natural resource governance and conflict that remains disconnected from lived experience. We question the utility of resource curse as a lens through which to view resource-conflict linkages by demonstrating how it fails to capture important aspects of the relationship between resource extraction, governance, and violent conflict.