Cytosponge-trefoil factor 3 versus usual care to identify Barrett's oesophagus in a primary care setting: a multicentre, pragmatic, randomised controlled trial. Issue 10247 (1st August 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Fitzgerald, Rebecca C; di Pietro, Massimiliano; O'Donovan, Maria; Maroni, Roberta; Muldrew, Beth; Debiram-Beecham, Irene; Gehrung, Marcel; Offman, Judith; Tripathi, Monika; Smith, Samuel G; Aigret, Benoit; Walter, Fiona M; Rubin, Greg; Sasieni, Peter; Bagewadi, Abhay; Patrick, Abigail; Shenoy, Achuth; Redmond, Aisling; Muddu, Ajay; Northrop, Alex; Groves, Alice; Shiner, Alice; Heer, Amardeep; Takhar, Amrit; Bowles, Amy; Jarman, Andrea; Wong, Angela; Lucas, Angie; Gibbons, Anita; Dhar, Anjan; Curry, Anji; Lalonde, Anna; Swinburn, Anna; Turner, Anne; Lydon, Anne-Marie; Gunstone, Anthony; Lee, Arlene; Nambi, Arul; Ariyarathenam, Arun; Elden, Ashley; Wilson, Ashley; Donepudi, Balaji; Campbell, Barbara; Uszycka, Basia; Bowers, Ben; Coghill, Ben; de Quadros, Bruno; Cheah, Calvin; Bratten, Carla; Brown, Carly; Moorbey, Chantelle; Clisby, Charles; Gordon, Charles; Schramm, Chris; Castle, Chris; Newark, Chris; Norris, Chrissie; A'Court, Christine; Graham, Claire; Fletcher, Clare; Grocott, Clare; Rees, Colin; Bakker, Corinne; Paschalides, Costas; Vickery, Craig; Schembri, Damian; Morris, Danielle; Hagan, Daryl; Cronk, David; Goddard, David; Graham, David; Phillips, Dean; Prabhu, Deeksha; Kejariwal, Deepak; Garg, Dhirendra; Lonsdale, Diane; Butterworth, Dianne; Clements, Donna; Bradman, Drew; Blake, Duncan; Mather, Elizabeth; O'Farrell, Ewan; Markowetz, Florian; Adams, Fran; Pesola, Francesca; Forbes, Gareth; Taylor, Gary; Collins, Glenn; Irvine, Gordon; Fourie, Gysbert; Doyle, Harriet; Barnes, Heather; Bowyer, Helen; Whiting, Helen; Beales, Ian; Binnian, Ian; Bremner, Ian; Jennings, Ian; Troiceanu, Ilona; Modelell, Ines; Emmerson, Ingrid; Ortiz, Jacobo; Lilley, Jacqueline; Harvey, Jacquelyn; Vicars, Jacqui; Takhar, Jagjit; Larcombe, James; Bornschein, Jan; Aldegather, Jehad; Johnson, Jenny; Ducker, Jill; Skinner, Jo; Dash, Joanne; Walsh, Joanne; Miralles, Jose; Ridgway, Josephine; Ince, Julia; Kennedy, Julie; Hampson, Kat; Milne, Kate; Ellerby, Katherine; Priddis, Katherine; Rainsbury, Kathy; Powell, Kelly; Gunner, Kerry; Ragunath, Krish; Knox, Kyle; Baseley, Laura; White, Lauren; Lovat, Laurence; Berney, Lee; Crockett, Lindsay; Murray, Lisa; Westwood, Lisa; Chalkley, Lisa; Leggett, Loraine; Dale, Louise; Scovell, Louise; Brooks, Lucy; Saunders, Lucy; Owen, Lydia; Dilwershah, Maria; Baldry, Marie; Corcoran, Marie; Roy, Marie; Macedo, Mario; Attah, Mark; Anson, Mary-Jo; Rutter, Matt; Wallard, Matthew; Gaw, Matthew; Hunt, Matthew; Lea-Hagerty, Megan; Penacerrada, Melchizedek; Bianchi, Michele; Baker-Moffatt, Michelle; Czajkowski, Michelle; Sleeth, Michelle; Brewer, Nick; Wooding, Nick; Todd, Nicky; Millen, Nicola; Zolle, Olga; Whitehead, Orla; Ojechi, Patrick; Moore, Patrick; Banim, Paul; Spellar, Paula; Bhandari, Pradeep; Kant, Prashant; Nixon, Rachel; Russell, Rebecca; Roberts, Rebekah; Skule, Rene; West, Richard; Fox, Robin; Beesley, Ruth; Gibbins, Ruth; Osborne, Ruth; Thiagarajan, S; Bastiman, Sally; Warburton, Samantha; Pai, Samir; Leith-Russell, Sarah; Utting, Sarah; Watson, Sarah; Wytrykowski, Sarah; Singh, Satish; Malhotra, Shalini; Woods, Sharon; Conway, Shaun; Mateer, Sherrie; Macrae, Shona; Singh, Shruti; Fourie, Simona; Campbell, Siobhan; Parslow-Williams, Siobhan; Goel, Sonica; Dellar, Stephen; Jones, Stephen; Knight, Steve; Mackay-Thomas, Stuart; Mukherjee, Stuti; Allen, Sue; Henry, Suzanne; Evans, Tara; Leighton, Theresa; Bray, Tim; Shackleton, Tom; Santosh, Vanaja; Glover, Vicki; Chandraraj, Vijay; Elson, Will; Briggs, William; Barron, Zoe; Khan, Zohrah;
• Is Part Of: Lancet. Volume 396:Issue 10247(2020)
• Page Start: 333
• Page End: 344
• Publication Date: 2020-08-01
• Subjects: Medicine -- Periodicals; Medicine -- Periodicals; Medicine; Medicine; Electronic journals; Periodicals; 610.5
• DOI: 10.1016/S0140-6736(20)31099-0
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0140-6736

Abstract

Summary: Background: Treatment of dysplastic Barrett's oesophagus prevents progression to adenocarcinoma; however, the optimal diagnostic strategy for Barrett's oesophagus is unclear. The Cytosponge-trefoil factor 3 (TFF3) is a non-endoscopic test for Barrett's oesophagus. The aim of this study was to investigate whether offering this test to patients on medication for gastro-oesophageal reflux would increase the detection of Barrett's oesophagus compared with standard management. Methods: This multicentre, pragmatic, randomised controlled trial was done in 109 socio-demographically diverse general practice clinics in England. Randomisation was done both at the general practice clinic level (cluster randomisation) and at the individual patient level, and the results for each type of randomisation were analysed separately before being combined. Patients were eligible if they were aged 50 years or older, had been taking acid-suppressants for symptoms of gastro-oesophageal reflux for more than 6 months, and had not undergone an endoscopy procedure within the past 5 years. General practice clinics were selected by the local clinical research network and invited to participate in the trial. For cluster randomisation, clinics were randomly assigned (1:1) by the trial statistician using a computer-generated randomisation sequence; for individual patient-level randomisation, patients were randomly assigned (1:1) by the general practice clinics using a centrally prepared computer-generated randomisation sequence. After randomisation, participants received either standard management of gastro-oesophageal reflux (usual care group), in which participants only received an endoscopy if required by their general practitioner, or usual care plus an offer of the Cytosponge-TFF3 procedure, with a subsequent endoscopy if the procedure identified TFF3-positive cells (intervention group). The primary outcome was the diagnosis of Barrett's oesophagus at 12 months after enrolment, expressed as a rate per 1000 person-years, in all participants in the intervention group (regardless of whether they had accepted the offer of the Cytosponge-TFF3 procedure) compared with all participants in the usual care group. Analyses were intention-to-treat. The trial is registered with the ISRCTN registry, ISRCTN68382401, and is completed. Findings: Between March 20, 2017, and March 21, 2019, 113 general practice clinics were enrolled, but four clinics dropped out shortly after randomisation. Using an automated search of the electronic prescribing records of the remaining 109 clinics, we identified 13 657 eligible patients who were sent an introductory letter with 14 days to opt out. 13 514 of these patients were randomly assigned (per practice or at the individual patient level) to the usual care group (n=6531) or the intervention group (n=6983). Following randomisation, 149 (2%) of 6983 participants in the intervention group and 143 (2%) of 6531 participants in the usual care group, on further scrutiny, did not meet all eligibility criteria or withdrew from the study. Of the remaining 6834 participants in the intervention group, 2679 (39%) expressed an interest in undergoing the Cytosponge-TFF3 procedure. Of these, 1750 (65%) met all of the eligibility criteria on telephone screening and underwent the procedure. Most of these participants (1654 [95%]; median age 69 years) swallowed the Cytosponge successfully and produced a sample. 231 (3%) of 6834 participants had a positive Cytosponge-TFF3 result and were referred for an endoscopy. Patients who declined the offer of the Cytosponge-TFF3 procedure and all participants in the usual care group only had an endoscopy if deemed necessary by their general practitioner. During an average of 12 months of follow-up, 140 (2%) of 6834 participants in the intervention group and 13 (<1%) of 6388 participants in the usual care group were diagnosed with Barrett's oesophagus (absolute difference 18·3 per 1000 person-years [95% CI 14·8–21·8]; rate ratio adjusted for cluster randomisation 10·6 [95% CI 6·0–18·8], p<0·0001). Nine (<1%) of 6834 participants were diagnosed with dysplastic Barrett's oesophagus (n=4) or stage I oesophago-gastric cancer (n=5) in the intervention group, whereas no participants were diagnosed with dysplastic Barrett's oesophagus or stage I gastro-oesophageal junction cancer in the usual care group. Among 1654 participants in the intervention group who swallowed the Cytosponge device successfully, 221 (13%) underwent endoscopy after testing positive for TFF3 and 131 (8%, corresponding to 59% of those having an endoscopy) were diagnosed with Barrett's oesophagus or cancer. One patient had a detachment of the Cytosponge from the thread requiring endoscopic removal, and the most common side-effect was a sore throat in 63 (4%) of 1654 participants. Interpretation: In patients with gastro-oesophageal reflux, the offer of Cytosponge-TFF3 testing results in improved detection of Barrett's oesophagus. Cytosponge-TFF3 testing could also lead to the diagnosis of treatable dysplasia and early cancer. This strategy will lead to additional endoscopies with some false positive results. Funding: Cancer Research UK, National Institute for Health Research, the UK National Health Service, Medtronic, and the Medical Research Council.