Beliefs About the Persistence of History in Objects and Spaces in the United States and India. (June 2020)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Marchak, Kristan A.; McLaughlin, Merranda; Noles, Nicholaus S.; Gelman, Susan A.
• Is Part Of: Journal of cross-cultural psychology. Volume 51:Number 5(2020)
• Page Start: 309
• Page End: 332
• Publication Date: 2020-06
• Subjects: history -- persistence -- paranormal beliefs -- religiosity -- essentialism -- cultural comparison; Ethnopsychology -- Periodicals; 155.805
• DOI: 10.1177/0022022120922312
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0022-0221

Abstract

Scattered evidence in the literature suggests that people may believe that non-visible traces of past events (e.g., origins, emotions, and qualities of the owner) persist over time in objects and spaces, even after the original source has been removed. To date, however, there has been no unified treatment to determine the scope and cultural consistency of this expectation. This study had four primary goals: (a) to assess how broadly participants display persistence-of-history beliefs, (b) to explore individual differences in these beliefs, (c) to examine the explanatory frameworks for these beliefs, and (d) to determine whether these beliefs were endorsed across two cultural settings. Adults in both United States ( N = 195) and India ( N = 173) evaluated a broad range of situations involving possible persistence of history. In both countries, three patterns emerged: (a) A broad range of persistence-of-history scenarios were judged to be possible, falling into two underlying thematic clusters (supernatural vs. non-supernatural); (b) paranormal beliefs predicted endorsement of items in both thematic clusters; and yet (c) most scenarios were explained using natural explanatory frameworks. Together, these results demonstrate broad endorsement of the persistence of history—across cultures, situations, and individuals—as well as substantial individual variation.