Taxonomy of cryptic species in the Cyornis rubeculoides complex in the Indian subcontinent. (2nd June 2019)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Singh, Ashutosh; Gupta, Sandeep K.; Alström, Per; Mohan, Dhananjai; Hooper, Daniel M.; Kumar, Ramani S.; Bhatt, Dinesh; Singh, Pratap; Price, Trevor D.
• Is Part Of: Ibis. Volume 162:Number 3(2020)
• Page Start: 924
• Page End: 935
• Publication Date: 2019-06-02
• Subjects: flycatcher -- phylogeny -- songs -- song playback; Birds -- Periodicals; 598
• DOI: 10.1111/ibi.12735
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0019-1019

Abstract

Abstract : Taxa classified as subspecies may in fact be cryptic species. We assessed the taxonomic status of the Blue‐throated Flycatcher Cyornis rubeculoides complex in India, which consists of several forms with similar plumages and song. We used mitochondrial and nuclear DNA, plumage traits, and detailed song analysis to ascertain the taxonomic status of the different forms. The molecular data identified three primary clades: (1) in the west Himalayan foothills, (2) at higher elevations in the northeast hill states of Meghalaya, Nagaland and Mizoram, and (3) at lower elevations in the northeastern hills of Meghalaya and the east Himalayas of Arunachal Pradesh. The western clade represents nominate C. rubeculoides rubeculoides . The high‐elevation eastern clade was considered to be C. rubeculoides rogersi, because it included a sample from this subspecies from near the type locality in southwest Myanmar. These two sister clades had an estimated divergence time of 1.5 million years (my). The low‐elevation east clade has previously been assigned to C. rubeculoides, but we showed it is closely related to the Hainan Blue Flycatcher Cyornis hainanus, formerly thought to breed only further east, with an estimated divergence time of only ~0.8 my. This clade may represent a subspecies of C. hainanus or, given reports of widespread sympatry with C. hainanus in Thailand, a distinct species, Cyornis dialilaemus . However, more research is advocated, including molecular data, from the area of overlap. Songs were remarkably similar across all taxa. In playback experiments, C. r . rubeculoides in the west responded to all taxa. This is in agreement with recent work demonstrating that song differences and responses to songs are not always a good indicator of the progress of reproductive isolation.