'This would be scary to any other culture … but to us it's so cute!' The radicalism of Fourth Cinema from Tangata Whenua to Angry Inuk. Issue 3 (2nd September 2019)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Vanstone, Gail; Winston, Brian
• Is Part Of: Studies in documentary film. Volume 13:Issue 3(2019)
• Page Start: 233
• Page End: 249
• Publication Date: 2019-09-02
• Subjects: Third Cinema -- Fourth Cinema -- documentary film -- radical film -- Indigeneity -- 'Indianess' -- settler education -- 'loving Indianess'; Documentary films -- Periodicals; Motion pictures -- Periodicals; Films documentaires -- Périodiques; Films documentaires -- Production et réalisation -- Périodiques; Cinéma -- Périodiques; Documentary films; Motion pictures; Periodicals; 070.18
• DOI: 10.1080/17503280.2019.1672919
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1750-3280

Abstract

ABSTRACT: Articulating the concept of a Fourth Cinema, Maori filmmaker, Barry Barclay highlighted its intrinsic radical possibilities for Indigenous documentary production. Departing from Solanas and Getino's Third Cinema theory, Barclay argues 'that some Indigenous film artists will be interested in shaping films that sit with confidence within the First, Second and Third cinema framework'. To take this view of documentary work by Indigenous filmmakers living in geographic territories where mainstream documentary was most influenced by John Grierson's interventions and legacy – Canada, New Zealand and Australia – recognises their presence in documentary's radical tradition. Fourth Cinema documentaries of seemingly unchallenging 'exteriority' (i.e. with 'surface features: rituals, language, posturing, décor, the use of elders, the presence of children, attitudes to land, rituals of a spirit world) are repositioned by the concept. When viewed through the 'right pair of [Indigenous] spectacles', their 'interiority' (i.e. 'the ancient core values' 'outside the national orthodoxy') is revealed. Fourth Cinema documentaries are thus not only radical when 'documenting injustices and claiming reparations' (Ginsburg). They also sit firmly within documentary's radical tradition by celebrating the Indigenous – 'making records of the lives and knowledge of elders' (Ginsburg) offering valuable knowledge to Indigenous and settler eyes.