To Kill or Not to Kill? The Challenge of Restraining Violence in a Balkan Community. (October 2019)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Bergholz, Max
• Is Part Of: Comparative studies in society and history. Volume 61:Number 4(2019:Oct.)
• Page Start: 954
• Page End: 985
• Publication Date: 2019-10
• Subjects: intercommunal violence, -- civil war, -- insurgency, -- restraint, -- genocide, -- variation, -- microhistory, -- Bosnia-Herzegovina, -- Independent State of Croatia, -- Balkans; Social sciences -- Periodicals; History -- Periodicals; 300
• DOI: 10.1017/S0010417519000318
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0010-4175

Abstract

Abstract: Explaining why restraint of violence becomes a strategy for armed groups has recently attracted the attention of researchers, especially political scientists. The emergent literature generally argues by way of macro-level statistical correlation, in which a single factor, such as the desire of armed groups to adhere to international norms about human rights or the existence of high levels of political education among fighters, is believed to explain the presence of restraint. Missing in this approach are close analyses of actual historical episodes of restraint. We thus lack comprehension of how those with ideas about restraining violence translate their thoughts into actions, especially in contexts such as civil wars. This article addresses this weakness by examining the history of a Balkan community wracked by intercommunal violence during 1941 to explain the puzzling practice of restraint in the midst of waves of retaliatory violence. Rather than identify a single factor, this micro-comparative case study reveals that a cluster of mostly endogenous factors, shaped significantly by ongoing violence, explains the successful practice of restraint. Methodologically, this article stresses the need for researchers of restraint to employ microhistorical and comparative methods. They hold the greatest potential to illuminate what remains insufficiently explained in the extant political science literature: the contingent local processes whereby a desire for restraint or escalation of violence—the existence of which may be conditioned by longer-term historical developments—becomes a reality in certain moments.