What are adult psychiatric inpatients' experience of seclusion: A systematic review of qualitative studies. Issue 7 (7th August 2019)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Askew, Louise; Fisher, Paul; Beazley, Peter
• Is Part Of: Journal of psychiatric and mental health nursing. Volume 26:Issue 7/8(2019)
• Page Start: 274
• Page End: 285
• Publication Date: 2019-08-07
• Subjects: patient experience -- qualitative methodology -- seclusion and restraint -- systematic literature reviews; Psychiatric nursing -- Periodicals; Psychiatric nurses -- Periodicals; Mental Disorders -- nursing -- Periodicals; Psychiatric Nursing -- Periodicals; 616.890231
• DOI: 10.1111/jpm.12537
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1351-0126

Abstract

Accessible summary: What is known on the subject?: Seclusion involves isolating a patient in a room away from other patients in order to contain aggressive behaviour, and it is used in psychiatric hospitals. Research has found that seclusion is often viewed by patients as negative; however, there is limited in‐depth understanding of the deeply personal experience. What this paper adds to existing knowledge?: This systematic review found that the published research may have flaws with the quality of analysis, mainly due to limited researcher reflexivity. The review of qualitative research revealed that during seclusion, patients feel vulnerable, neglected and abused, disconnected from the experience and that it is dangerous to their mental health. What are the implications for practice?: For clinicians facilitating the seclusion process to use their therapeutic skills to provide patients with a sense of being cared for. For clinical supervision to allow space to explore interpersonal dynamics during seclusion in order to enhance therapeutic staff–patient interaction. Abstract: Introduction: There is limited understanding of patients' seclusion experience. A 2013 systematic review provides some insight; however, more knowledge is required in order to improve patient care. This is a systematic review of qualitative research into the patient experience of seclusion. The qualitative focus enables the phenomena to be the central focus. Question: "What are adult psychiatric inpatients' experience of seclusion?" and "What is the quality of the applicable research?" Method: Electronic searches for qualitative research published between 2006 and 2017 were undertaken. Data were excluded if it was not explicitly related to seclusion. Research was appraised using three standardized appraisal criterion. Themes were generated through thematic synthesis. Results: Eight papers met inclusion criteria; four had been translated into English. Four themes were identified: "feeling vulnerable, " "feeling neglected and abused, " "disconnecting" and "seclusion is dangerous to mental health." Participants felt vulnerable and without control. They experienced staff and room as neglectful and abusive. Participants mentally disconnected. The experience threatened participants' mental health. Discussion: Participants' experience is an amalgamation of interpersonal experience and the environment. Disconnecting may be a coping strategy. Implications for practice: The findings have implications for seclusion practice, staff training and clinical supervision. Specific attention needs to be paid to the staff–patient interaction.