Blind test evaluation of consistency in macroscopic lithic raw material sorting. Issue 4 (16th December 2018)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Agam, Aviad; Wilson, Lucy
• Is Part Of: Geoarchaeology. Volume 34:Issue 4(2019)
• Page Start: 467
• Page End: 477
• Publication Date: 2018-12-16
• Subjects: blind tests -- lithic raw materials -- macroscopic analysis; Archaeological geology -- Periodicals; 930.1028
• DOI: 10.1002/gea.21720
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0883-6353

Abstract

Abstract: Most archaeological lithic raw material studies depend upon a macroscopic classification. However, since the human eye is a limited tool, some inconsistencies in classification may arise. Thus, a process for evaluating and increasing the reliability of macroscopic classification is needed. We present the results of a blind test designed to evaluate consistency in macroscopic lithic materials analysis, based on archaeological material taken from the Acheulo‐Yabrudian site Qesem Cave (Israel), focusing on interobserver error, aimed at identifying consistencies and weaknesses within our own study scheme. Twelve students, with various degrees of experience and familiarity with the Qesem material, sorted 100 randomly selected flint pieces into flint types, based on a previously established database, after a brief tutorial process. In addition, the authors, LW and AA, performed the same test. We then compared the results, using LW's results as an anchor. Our results show that experience affects the consistency in classification, demonstrating that it is an acquired skill. Furthermore, the blind test allowed us to identify weaknesses within the classification scheme. We suggest that blind tests should be regularly used to check accuracy and reproducibility of results and to assess the definitions set by the analyst, allowing fine‐tuning and calibration of the classification process.