Identifying and Modeling Dynamic Preference Evolution in Multipurpose Water Resources Systems. Issue 4 (29th April 2018)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Mason, E.; Giuliani, M.; Castelletti, A.; Amigoni, F.
• Is Part Of: Water resources research. Volume 54:Issue 4(2018)
• Page Start: 3162
• Page End: 3175
• Publication Date: 2018-04-29
• Subjects: water management -- negotiation protocol -- tradeoff analysis -- multipurpose reservoir -- coupled human‐natural systems -- sociohydrology; Hydrology -- Periodicals; 333.91
• DOI: 10.1002/2017WR021431
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0043-1397

Abstract

Abstract: Multipurpose water systems are usually operated on a tradeoff of conflicting operating objectives. Under steady state climatic and socioeconomic conditions, such tradeoff is supposed to represent a fair and/or efficient preference. Extreme variability in external forcing might affect water operators' risk aversion and force a change in her/his preference. Properly accounting for these shifts is key to any rigorous retrospective assessment of the operator's behaviors, and to build descriptive models for projecting the future system evolution. In this study, we explore how the selection of different preferences is linked to variations in the external forcing. We argue that preference selection evolves according to recent, extreme variations in system performance: underperforming in one of the objectives pushes the preference toward the harmed objective. To test this assumption, we developed a rational procedure to simulate the operator's preference selection. We map this selection onto a multilateral negotiation, where multiple virtual agents independently optimize different objectives. The agents periodically negotiate a compromise policy for the operation of the system. Agents' attitudes in each negotiation step are determined by the recent system performance measured by the specific objective they maximize. We then propose a numerical model of preference dynamics that implements a concept from cognitive psychology, the availability bias. We test our modeling framework on a synthetic lake operated for flood control and water supply. Results show that our model successfully captures the operator's preference selection and dynamic evolution driven by extreme wet and dry situations. Key Points: We explore how variability in hydroclimatic forcing may produce a change in the preferences of multipurpose water systems' operators We map the identification of the preference among multiple objectives onto a multilateral negotiation process We model preference dynamics via periodic negotiations implementing the availability bias concept from cognitive psychology