The man within the breast, the supreme impartial spectator, and other impartial spectators in Adam Smith's The Theory of Moral Sentiments. Issue 8 (17th November 2018)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Klein, Daniel B.; Matson, Erik W.; Doran, Colin
• Is Part Of: History of European ideas. Volume 44:Issue 8(2018)
• Page Start: 1153
• Page End: 1168
• Publication Date: 2018-11-17
• Subjects: Adam Smith -- The Theory of Moral Sentiments -- philosophy -- the impartial spectator -- the man within the breast -- God; A13 -- B12 -- B31; Europe -- Intellectual life -- Periodicals; Europe -- History -- Periodicals; 190.5
• DOI: 10.1080/01916599.2018.1485001
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0191-6599

Abstract

ABSTRACT: Adam Smith infused the expression 'impartial spectator' with a plexus of related meanings, one of which is a super-being, which bears parallels to monotheistic ideas of God. As for any genuine, identified, human spectator, he can be deemed impartial only presumptively. Such presumptive impartiality as regards the incident does not of itself carry extensive implications about his intelligence, nor about his being aligned with benevolence towards any larger whole. We may posit, however, a being who is impartial and who holds higher levels of intelligence and of benevolence, and then converse over what her sentiments would be about the matter under discussion. It is natural to conceive of a being who is unsurpassable in such qualities, who is morally supreme, and who naturally takes the definite article the without having been definitized by the writer (because unnecessary, just as we speak of 'the world'). Signal passages, new to edition 6, suggest that Smith formulates the man within the breast as a representative of the always present and everywhere morally supreme impartial spectator. When Smith speaks of the man within the breast as 'the supposed impartial spectator' (all new to edition 6), we interpret 'supposed' as sup-pos-ed (purported), not sup-pos'd (posited).