Attainment Grouping as self-fulfilling prophesy? A mixed methods exploration of self confidence and set level among Year 7 students. (2017)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Francis, Becky; Connolly, Paul; Archer, Louise; Hodgen, Jeremy; Mazenod, Anna; Pepper, David; Sloan, Seaneen; Taylor, Becky; Tereshchenko, Antonina; Travers, Mary-Claire
• Is Part Of: International journal of educational research. Volume 86(2017)
• Page Start: 96
• Page End: 108
• Publication Date: 2017
• Subjects: Tracking -- Ability -- Setting -- Pupil grouping -- Inequality -- Self confidence -- Self concept -- Self-fulfilling prophecy; Education -- Evaluation -- Periodicals; Curriculum evaluation -- Periodicals; Education -- Periodicals; Program Evaluation -- Periodicals; Éducation -- Évaluation -- Périodiques; Programmes d'études -- Evaluation -- Périodiques; Éducation -- Recherche -- Périodiques; Curriculum evaluation; Education -- Evaluation; Periodicals; 370.72
• DOI: 10.1016/j.ijer.2017.09.001
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0883-0355

Abstract

Highlights: Placement in 'ability sets' impacts pupil self-confidence in learning. This is the case for the subjects in which they are set, and for broader self-confidence in learning. Supports self-fulfilling prophecy as explanation for low-attainers' poorer results. Qualitative data reveals damaging impact of placement in low sets on self-perception. Abstract: Within-school segregation of pupils by attainment remains prevalent, despite evidence that these practices detrimentally impact outcomes for those in low attainment groups. This article explores the hypothesis that 'ability grouping' by setting impacts pupil self-confidence, precipitating a self-fulfilling prophecy. Survey data from 11, 546 11/12 year old pupils in 'ability sets', and individual interviews and focus groups with 66 pupils, are drawn upon to explore this hypothesis. We find a significant correlation between perceived set placement and self-confidence in the set subject. More importantly, we also find a correlation between set placement and general self-confidence in learning. Pupils' qualitative responses illustrate how setting can promote self-fulfilling prophecy, and worrying evidence of internalisation of 'ability' labels among pupils.