Comparing Cognitive Efficiency of Experienced and Inexperienced Designers in Conceptual Design Processes. (December 2014)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Sun, Ganyun; Yao, Shengji; Carretero, Juan A.
• Other Names: Caldwell Barrett S. guest-editor.; Jones Patricia M. guest-editor.
• Is Part Of: Journal of cognitive engineering and decision making. Volume 8:Number 4(2014:Dec.)
• Page Start: 330
• Page End: 351
• Publication Date: 2014-12
• Subjects: cognitive efficiency -- cognitive load -- mental effort -- creativity -- conceptual design; Human-computer interaction -- Periodicals; User-centered system design -- Periodicals; 004.019
• DOI: 10.1177/1555343414540172
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1555-3434

Abstract

Design cognition research aims to investigate the cognitive mechanisms and thought processes of human designers. In previous research, the cognitive activity of experienced and inexperienced designers has been compared in order to identify design strategies leading to design creativity. However, it is still unknown whether the design strategies applied are effective and whether the design processes are efficiently improved. In this paper, cognitive efficiency, describing how designers optimize mental resources to achieve creativity in conceptual design processes, was directly measured by the mental effort of designers and the creativity level of design outcomes. The results showed that the experienced designers generated more design concepts with higher quality and variety than did the inexperienced designers. The cognitive efficiency measures indicated that design expertise contributed to improving cognitive efficiency scores of quality. In addition, the systematic design method used by some designers was found to be related to high cognitive efficiency. It can be seen that the evaluation of cognitive efficiency has practical applications for designer training, design methodology evaluation, and design process improvement.