Moments of Uncertainty: Ethical Considerations and Emerging Contaminants1. Issue 3 (23rd August 2013)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Cordner, Alissa; Brown, Phil
• Is Part Of: Sociological forum. Volume 28:Issue 3(2013:Sep.)
• Page Start: 469
• Page End: 494
• Publication Date: 2013-08-23
• Subjects: biomonitoring -- emerging contaminants -- ethics -- professional conduct -- risk and uncertainty -- sociology of science; Sociology -- Periodicals; 301
• DOI: 10.1111/socf.12034
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 0884-8971

Abstract

Abstract : Science on emerging environmental health threats involves numerous ethical concerns related to scientific uncertainty about conducting, interpreting, communicating, and acting upon research findings, but the connections between ethical decision making and scientific uncertainty are under‐studied in sociology. Under conditions of scientific uncertainty, researcher conduct is not fully prescribed by formal ethical codes of conduct, increasing the importance of ethical reflection by researchers, conflicts over research conduct, and reliance on informal ethical standards. This article draws on in‐depth interviews with scientists, regulators, activists, industry representatives, and fire safety experts to explore ethical considerations of moments of uncertainty using a case study of flame retardants, chemicals widely used in consumer products with potential negative health and environmental impacts. We focus on the uncertainty that arises in measuring people's exposure to these chemicals through testing of their personal environments or bodies. We identify four sources of ethical concerns relevant to scientific uncertainty: 1) choosing research questions or methods, 2) interpreting scientific results, 3) communicating results to multiple publics, and 4) applying results for policy making. This research offers lessons about professional conduct under conditions of uncertainty, ethical research practice, democratization of scientific knowledge, and science's impact on policy.