Validation of alternative capillary electrophoresis detection of STRs using POP-6 polymer and a 22 cm array on a 3130xl genetic analyzer. (May 2016)

• Record Type: Journal Article
• Authors: Connon, Catherine C.; LeFebvre, Aaron K.; Benjamin, Robert C.
• Is Part Of: Forensic science international. Volume 22(2016:May)
• Page Start: 113
• Page End: 127
• Publication Date: 2016-05
• Subjects: Forensic science -- Capillary electrophoresis -- Alternative detection -- Resolution -- Precision; Forensic genetics -- Periodicals; Génétique légale -- Périodiques; Forensic genetics; Electronic journals; Periodicals; 614.1
• DOI: 10.1016/j.fsigen.2016.02.006
• Languages: English
• ISSNs: 1872-4973

Abstract

Highlights: A detection method is presented that utilizes POP-6 polymer and 22 cm array. Detection time is reduced by ∼40% and sample throughput is increased ∼67%. Full allele concordance is achieved without panel and bin modifications. Resolution is slightly improved for smaller sized alleles (<200 b). One base resolution is achievable for allele sizes of up to 300 b. Abstract: The goal of this project was to reduce capillary electrophoresis detection time on a 3130 xl Genetic Analyzer for amplification product obtained from 4-dye and 5-dye STR amplification kits while still generating high quality STR profiles. This was accomplished by utilizing a more viscous polymer (POP-6™) and a shorter array (22 cm) than that which are typically used (POP-4 ® polymer and a 36 cm array) for human identification purposes. Spatial calibration and detection run modules were modified in response to the use of this polymer/array combination and to reduce detection time. Alternative detection resulted in 24–28 min run times, as compared to ∼45 min using traditional POP-4 ® /36 cm detection methods. POP-6™/22 cm detection run modules were validated for use with 4-dye Promega STR kits (e.g., PowerPlex ® 16 and PowerPlex ® 16HS) and 5-dye Life Technologies kits (e.g., Identifiler ® and Identifiler ® Plus). Three hundred ninety-five samples, controls and allelic ladders were used for the validation studies, which consisted of a comparison of alternative POP-6™/22 cm detection to traditional POP‐4 ® /36 cm (including reproducibility/concordance of allele calls, resolution, ILS sizing quality, peak height and pass rates), a sizing study (precision and accuracy) and a sensitivity study to obtain a usable range of injection times. Compared to traditional POP-4 ® /36 cm detection, alternative detection resulted in 100% reproducible and concordant alleles, the ability to achieve one base resolution, slightly reduced ILS sizing quality, slightly reduced peak height and statistically similar pass rates ( α = 0.05). It should be noted that alternative detection offered improved resolution over that of traditional for amplicons less than ∼200 b, but had reduced resolution for products greater than ∼200 b. Additionally, alternative detection yielded acceptable precision and accuracy of sizing using Life Technologies criteria (<0.15 standard deviation of allele sizing and ±0.5 b sizing differences for the same allele) and usable injection parameters of 2 kV 4–15 s (compared to 3 kV 10 s for traditional). The run modules developed and validated for 4-dye and 5-dye STR kits using POP‐6™ polymer on a 22 cm array offer a tremendous reduction in detection time (∼40%) while still generating high quality STR profiles.